Probably not. Kalshi's market on Shohei Ohtani pitching again in the 2026 regular season last traded at 4 cents on the afternoon the Dodgers scrapped his comeback start against Detroit. Nothing has traded since.
The reason is the calendar. The contract pays out only if he throws one regular-season pitch before September 28, and Ohtani has not pitched since July 3. His Friday bullpen was cut short by left knee discomfort, and the team pulled the Sunday start with no new date attached. As of September 3 the best standing bid was 19 cents.
Stay ahead of the markets.
Daily insights and expert picks on Kalshi, Polymarket, and what's moving markets.
Free forever. Unsubscribe anytime.
The Board
The contract, KXMLBPITCH-26SOHTANI17, settles Yes on "at least 1 pitch in a Pro Baseball regular season game after Jul 28, 2026 and before Sep 28, 2026," so a playoff-only return settles No, and the league-neutral "Pro Baseball" wording is the phrase to hold onto if a minor-league rehab outing ever enters the picture. Each contract pays $1.00 on Yes and nothing on No, so a price in cents reads as an implied probability.
| Market | Prior session | Morning after the scratch (Aug 30) | Now (Sep 3) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ohtani To Pitch Again In 2026: Yes bid | 91¢ | 8¢ | 19¢ |
| Ohtani To Pitch Again In 2026: Yes ask | 95¢ | 76¢ | 76¢ |
| Ohtani To Pitch Again In 2026: last trade | 86¢ | 4¢ | 4¢ (Aug 29, no trade since) |
| Ohtani To Win NL MVP: last trade | 37¢ | 12¢ (13¢ bid) | 9¢ (9¢ bid) |
August 30 quotes captured that morning (about 6:15 UTC) from Kalshi's public market data; September 3 quotes captured about 12:30 p.m. ET. Pitching-market open interest 3,118 on both days, 6,320 contracts traded lifetime, zero in the trailing 24 hours on September 3. NL MVP open interest 423,039 on August 30 and 456,260 on September 3, with Pete Crow-Armstrong at 89 cents. Prices move constantly; this is a snapshot, not advice.
Why The Bid Fell 83 Cents In One Session
The comeback plan died in about 48 hours. On Friday, Ohtani threw a bullpen of about 20 pitches, 10 to 15 shorter than his normal between-starts work, because the left knee would not cooperate. On Saturday, Dave Roberts told reporters he is "not 100 percent" in either the knee or his right biceps, and the team scrapped the start it had lined up for Sunday against Detroit.
The injury itself dates to July 3, when his right biceps tightened during an at-bat in a game he had started on the mound. He was also managing left knee soreness that needed an injection over the All-Star break, and the biceps trouble stemmed from his upper body compensating for the knee. Every step of the rehab since has slipped, most recently from a penciled-in start to no date at all.
The whole sell-off was one sweep on the afternoon of August 29 that cleared mostly at 24 cents and bottomed at 4. Holders who owned Yes in the 90s faced the choice every owner of a collapsing contract faces, the one we walked through in cash out or let it ride on Kalshi, and they took whatever was underneath them.
Is 19 Bid, 76 Ask A Coin Flip?
No. A midpoint means something only when both sides of the quote are live. The 76-cent ask has had the same 26 or so contracts behind it since before the crash, a limit order from the market's previous life that nobody has bothered to cancel or undercut.
The bid is real money, 100 contracts at 19 cents, but the book under it is a cliff: 65 more contracts at 18, then nothing of size until 5 cents. The bid-ask spread on Kalshi is the price of trading immediately, and a 57-cent gap means one side of the book has been abandoned.
The bid climbed four straight sessions on zero volume, from 7 cents the day of the scratch to 22 cents at Wednesday's close. By midday Thursday it had eased to 19. That is a few buyers raising and trimming limit orders into a book where the holders who did not sell into the sweep have decided to sit. If any seller had crossed, there would be a print above 4 cents. There is none.
What The Dodgers Have Said Since
On Wednesday, September 2, Roberts said a shutdown from pitching remains a possibility but that the Dodgers will not make that decision yet, per ClutchPoints. Per Dodger Blue, he put a floor under the timeline: "I do stand by nothing's going to happen until potentially Sunday. But I do think that there's going to be a conversation that needs to be had this week about what the outlook is, and we haven't had it yet."
The same day, as Yahoo Sports relayed from Katie Woo of The Athletic, Andrew Friedman said there has been no talk of shutting Ohtani down: "We will get him in a game at some point. When? I don't know exactly yet." So the throwing program continues, and the earliest anything changes is Sunday, September 6, which would leave 22 days inside the contract's window.
Roberts has also said he does not expect the knee to feel 100 percent at any point this season while Ohtani is pitching, and that "his value offensively is hugely important, and so we can't compromise that in any fashion." Ohtani has hit .202/.288/.416 since the weekend he resumed bullpen sessions.
What The 19 Cents Is Buying
The Yes case is not zero, and the market says so by bidding 19 rather than 1. One pitch is all the rules require. If the knee calms down, the outlook conversation lands on the right side and a bullpen goes clean, a mid-September start against a soft opponent resolves this Yes with about two weeks to spare. Roberts himself noted that "there's a lot of pitchers that are not 100% and still viable," and per MLB Trade Rumors the team has not decided he is done for the year.
Weigh what the Dodgers are optimizing for, though. Their October ceiling depends on Ohtani the hitter far more than on four regular-season innings from Ohtani the pitcher, and Roberts said out loud that if throwing cuts into the offense, "that's not worth the squeeze." Per Dodger Blue, Friedman's hope is to have Ohtani available to pitch in the playoffs, potentially in a limited role. A front office that gets what it wants from an October-only Ohtani has little reason to spend a September start buying it, and a postseason debut settles this contract No. The Yes side needs the knee to heal, the biceps to hold, the training staff to sign off and the front office to want a tune-up, all before September 28. Nineteen cents for that parlay of ifs might even be generous.
Does The Deeper Book Agree?
Yes. Ohtani's NL MVP contract fell from a 37-cent last trade to 12 in the same session as the scratch, on a book roughly 135 times the pitching market's size, and has kept sliding to 9 cents since. A thin book can spook itself; 423,039 open contracts repricing the same fact at the same time is information.
When we wrote up the NL MVP race in August, Ohtani was a 42-cent contract trading haymakers with Pete Crow-Armstrong, who now sits at 89. Voters were always going to weigh the two-way season, and the two-way season is what the scratch put in doubt.
Markets like this trade on Kalshi rather than a sportsbook, so OddsShopper's tools do not carry them, but the same discipline of taking the price that has money behind it is what our live MLB odds screen is built for on Dodgers game lines.
The Bottom Line
Watch Sunday. The outlook conversation Roberts promised is the only thing that can move this board before September 28, and the price will tell you before the press conference does. The daily Kalshi picks page grades it every morning.
More on this: Shohei Ohtani NL Cy Young Odds: Can A Part-Time Pitcher Beat Full-Time Aces? · NL MVP Odds: The Wrigley Night Kalshi Turned On Ohtani · Can Shohei Ohtani Win NL MVP And NL Cy Young In The Same Season?
