The 78th Emmy Awards were read on Monday, September 14, 2026, and Kalshi's answer to the question in this page's title was right twice. The Pitt repeated as Outstanding Drama Series from a 95-cent price, and Widow's Bay won Outstanding Comedy Series from 88, on its way to 14 trophies, the most a comedy has won in one year. Across the 18 boards the telecast settled, the favorite at 8 PM ET paid on 14. The four that lost were all acting and directing undercards, and the winners came from 1, 5, 14 and 25 cents.
The eight-model panel this page was built on split the same way it split in August. It had The Pitt and was right. It had Hacks over Widow's Bay, every seat, and Hacks won two trophies to Widow's Bay's 14. That grade, the per-show count ladders that had The Pitt at 11 cents for the six it actually won, and the one contract that traded more than any other Emmy market and finished worth nothing are all below.
The Quick Answer
- Drama Series: The Pitt won. It was 95¢ at 8 PM ET and the panel's August pick at 55.5%. All prices below are from the Kalshi API as of 12:51 AM ET on September 15, 2026.
- Comedy Series: Widow's Bay won. It was 88¢ at 8 PM ET; the panel had Hacks at 42.8% and Widow's Bay at 33.5%, so the panel's order was wrong.
- The Scorecard: 14 of 18 favorites paid. The misses were Matthew Rhys from 25¢ over Oscar Isaac at 75, Allison Janney from 5¢ over Katherine LaNasa at 80, Sally Field from 14¢ over Carey Mulligan at 38, and Slow Horses from 1¢ over Pluribus at 67 for drama directing.
- The Count Ladders: every ladder now prices the real total, and the biggest repricing was The Pitt's Exactly 6 rung, 11¢ before the show and 95¢ bid after it. Pluribus' Exactly 6 went from 35¢ to 99.
- The Tie: the Variety Series Tie contract, 26¢ at 7:58 PM ET and the most-traded Emmy contract on the exchange, settled No when The Late Show with Stephen Colbert won alone.
The full 18-board table, the weekend boards, and how the panel's numbers score against the market's are below.
Stay ahead of the markets.
Daily insights and expert picks on Kalshi, Polymarket, and what's moving markets.
Free forever. Unsubscribe anytime.
Where The Market Was Right
Neither favorite on the two boards this page tracked from August 1 lost, though The Pitt's board wobbled for an hour, which is below. The Pitt's contract last traded at 95 cents before the telecast and its Pluribus challenger at 8; the exchange settled the drama board at 11:46 PM ET. Widow's Bay was 88 and Hacks 10 at 7:59 PM, and the comedy board settled at 12:08 AM. The market's read on comedy, a debut with 19 nominations beating a former champion with 24, was the one this page's panel argued against for six weeks, and the trophy count is the whole argument now. Widow's Bay took six telecast awards on top of its eight from the Creative Arts weekend: series, writing, directing for Hiro Murai, Matthew Rhys, Stephen Root and Kate O'Flynn. The Chicago Sun-Times has the record it set: 14, one more than The Studio's 13 last year.
The undercards the pre-show trading had moved toward also paid. Tom Pelphrey, who had passed Patrick Ball for the supporting-actor-in-a-drama lead in early September, won from 48 cents. Ball was 38 and Shawn Hatosy 20 before the show, and Pelphrey's contract traded at 99 by 9:00 PM ET. Stephen Root won supporting actor in a comedy from 51 cents against Harrison Ford at 41. That was one of two boards on the night where a favorite with only a 10-cent lead paid, Pelphrey's was the other, and it was decided at 8:40 PM. Rhea Seehorn won lead actress in a drama for Pluribus from 88. Jean Smart, Noah Wyle and Matthew Rhys, the three contracts above 90 cents on the acting boards since August, all paid, and the exchange had settled all three by 10:26 PM.
The Four Misses, In The Order They Happened
Matthew Rhys, 8:20 PM ET. The first miss of the night came 20 minutes in. Lead Actor in a Limited or Anthology Series or Movie was priced as Oscar Isaac's, 75 cents for Beef against Rhys at 25 for The Beast in Me. The order on this board matters because Rhys' comedy contract, 96 cents for Widow's Bay, was still to come. At 8:20:29 PM a buyer took 1,000 contracts of Rhys at 22 cents and 995 more at 29 four seconds later; by 8:20:43 it was 99. The Associated Press puts the two wins together with his 2018 drama award for The Americans: "With his two latest wins, Rhys is the first performer to ever win a lead acting Emmy for drama, comedy and limited series."
Allison Janney, 8:23 PM ET. Three minutes later came the biggest favorite to lose. Katherine LaNasa of The Pitt had led Supporting Actress in a Drama Series since August 1 and was 80 cents at 7:59 PM; Janney's contract had traded 11 times all day, every one at 5 cents. At 8:23:12 PM it traded at 71, 73 and 78 in the same second, and 16 seconds later a 1,000-contract trade went through at 99. LaNasa was a penny by 8:24.
Sally Field, 9:13 PM ET. Lead Actress in a Limited or Anthology Series or Movie had no favorite worth the name: Carey Mulligan 38, Sarah Pidgeon 33, Field 14 and Sarah Snook 11 before the show, on a board where Pidgeon had traded at 43 a day earlier. Field's contract traded at 99 at 9:13 PM on 976 contracts and settled at 10:26. The money had split this board three ways and missed the winner anyway.
Slow Horses, 9:34 PM ET. Outstanding Directing for a Drama Series is the miss that changed two other boards. Pluribus was 67 cents at 7:58 PM and The Pitt 32 at 7:54; Slow Horses had traded 14 times on Monday, all at a cent or two, on a row that had done about 17,000 contracts before the award was read. At 9:34:18 PM Slow Horses traded at 95 on 1,746 contracts, then 3,000 more a second later, and Pluribus went from 30 to a penny in the next 82 seconds. It also started the only stretch all night when the drama favorite was tested. The Pitt's series contract, 95 before the show, dropped under 90 at 9:42 PM, eight minutes after the directing upset, and traded 88 on a 908-contract fill at 9:45. It stayed under 90 for most of the next hour, as low as 67 cents at 10:04 PM, with 13,797 contracts changing hands below 90 in all, before a 2,015-contract minute at 10:40 PM took it back to 99. The timing points to the directing upset; the one other drama award of the window, writing, went to Pluribus on a category Kalshi had no board for, so the dip may have had two causes.
The Count Ladders Had The Wrong Total For Three Shows
Kalshi's per-show ladders, one yes/no contract on every possible final trophy count, are the boards that had the most to reprice, because the telecast decides every rung at once. They have not settled yet; every rung still carries a December 31 expiration, so the prices below are where the market moved, not the exchange's answer. The counts themselves are from the Television Academy's winners list added to each show's Creative Arts total.
| Show | Final Total | Correct Rung, Last Trade Before 8 PM ET | Highest-Priced Rung Before 8 PM (Last Trade) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Widow's Bay | 14 | Exactly 14, 21¢ | Exactly 13 (41¢ last trade) |
| The Pitt | 6 | Exactly 6, 11¢ | Exactly 8 (35¢) |
| Pluribus | 6 | Exactly 6, 35¢ | Exactly 7 (35¢), a dead heat with 6 |
| DTF St. Louis | 7 | Exactly 7, 86¢ | Exactly 7 |
| Hacks | 2 | Exactly 2, 31¢ | Exactly 2 |
| Beef | 3 | Exactly 3, 34¢ | Exactly 4 (39¢) |
Prices are each rung's last trade before 8 PM ET on September 14, on rungs that traded Monday; the Hacks ladder's Exactly 10 rung still shows an older 93-cent trade on 444 contracts and did not trade at all on Monday. By 12:51 AM ET on September 15 the correct rung was bid between 93 and 99 cents on all six ladders. The Widow's Bay ladder's Exactly 14 rung traded between 10 and 47 cents on Monday before the show, which says how little anyone was sure of a sweep.
The Pitt row is the one to read. Its ladder had been pricing eight or nine wins since the weekend: Exactly 8 at 35 cents an hour before the show and Exactly 9 at 28 20 minutes out, against 11 for Exactly 6 at the same moment. The show sat on five telecast boards, and it won two: the series and Noah Wyle. LaNasa lost to Janney, Ball lost to Pelphrey, and the directing board went to Slow Horses, so the count stopped at six, and the Exactly 6 rung did not trade above 15 cents until 9:37 PM ET, three minutes after the third of those three losses. Pluribus' ladder was a coin flip between 6 and 7, both at 35, and it needed one more telecast win to reach seven; the likeliest one, directing at 67 cents, went to Slow Horses. Widow's Bay's ladder was the surprise the other way: the correct rung was the third choice on its own ladder, behind 13 and 12, and it did not trade above 50 cents until 9:07 PM ET.
The Tie Contract, Settled
This page had tracked one contract more than any other since the Creative Arts weekend: Tie, on the Outstanding Variety Series board, where a merged area award and a rule sheet with no multi-winner clause made it the second favorite at 25 to 32 cents for a week. It finished as the most-traded Emmy contract on the exchange, 169,777 contracts lifetime, and it settled No.
The Late Show with Stephen Colbert was 72 cents at 7:59 PM ET and the Tie 26 a minute earlier. At 9:36:41 PM the Late Show traded at 95 on 1,685 contracts, and in the same second the Tie started trading in single digits. Over the next 34 seconds 12,766 contracts of it changed hands, 8,473 of them at a penny, including trades of 2,656 and 2,302 contracts in the same second at 9:36:59. Kalshi settled the board at 10:47 PM: Late Show Yes, Tie No, and the multi-winner question the rule text never answered did not need answering, because the Academy named one winner. The Late Show finished with six Emmys for the year per the Sun-Times, five of them from the weekend.
The Panel's Report Card
The eight seats priced both series boards on August 1 without seeing a market number, and their calls were frozen on this page since. Scored against the settlement, the market beat the panel on both boards. The table uses the Brier score, the average squared gap between a probability and the result across a board's nine contracts, where lower is better and zero is perfect; the market's August 1 cents are rescaled to sum to 100 before scoring.
| Board | Kalshi, Aug. 1 (Rescaled) | Panel Blend | Winner | Panel's Pick |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Drama Series | 0.005 | 0.031 | The Pitt | The Pitt |
| Comedy Series | 0.043 | 0.071 | Widow's Bay | Hacks |
The drama gap is the panel's lack of conviction in a winner it had picked. The blend gave The Pitt 55.5% against a market near 80% after rescaling, and every seat put Vince Gilligan's Pluribus second, 26.8% on a contract the market sold for 7 cents; Pluribus won six Emmys on the year and none of them was the series. The comedy gap is the order. All eight seats picked Hacks, and the case they made, a former champion returning as the most-nominated comedy while three Apple shows split one platform's campaign, was a reasonable one that the voters did not buy. The seat that came closest was the Gemini seat, which cut its Hacks number to 44.5 in the revision round because "the Academy loves a buzzy freshman comedy." It still had Hacks first. The error was in what the seats could weigh: nomination counts and a former champion are on the card, and a first season the voters liked enough for 14 trophies is not.
What the panel did get right, on both boards, was the shape of the tail. It called the Tie rows noise at 4 cents and they settled No. It said no series wins with eight or fewer nominations, and none did. Its one live longshot on the drama side, Slow Horses at 4.7% against a 1-cent price, did not win the series board, but the same show took the directing envelope from a penny on the board the panel never scored. Both calls, with the settlement, go on the full scoreboard.
My Take
I spent six weeks on this page arguing that the comedy board was the interesting one, and it was, for the wrong reason. The market had it right from the first day, and the panel's structural case for Hacks, a former champion with the most nominations in the field, lost to a show none of the seats had watched and the voters plainly had. What I would keep from this cycle is the pattern on the misses. All four came on single-envelope acting and directing boards where the favorite was between 38 and 80 cents, and three of the four winners had traded under 15 cents all day. The deep boards, the two series races and the most-awards contract, which had Widow's Bay at 92 cents before the show, all went the favorite's way, though the most-awards board is bid 99 and not yet settled, and the one hour The Pitt spent under 90 cents followed a directing upset, not anything in its own category. On Emmy night the money knows the shows. It still guesses at the voters on the undercards, and the Slow Horses directing board is the proof: its 1-cent contract was not a stale price nobody had checked, it had about 17,000 contracts behind it before the award, and it was still wrong. The two open Emmy boards left on the exchange, the count ladders and the most-awards contract, price the real totals now and wait on the exchange to close them.
Every Telecast Board, Settled
Eighteen boards were read on the telecast. "Price at 8 PM" is the winner's last trade before the broadcast; "Leader at 8 PM" is listed only where it was someone else. Settlement times are the exchange's, in ET.
| Board | Winner | Price At 8 PM | Leader At 8 PM | Settled |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Drama Series | The Pitt | 95¢ | 11:46 PM | |
| Comedy Series | Widow's Bay | 88¢ | 12:08 AM | |
| Limited Or Anthology Series | DTF St. Louis | 88¢ | 11:43 PM | |
| Variety Series | The Late Show with Stephen Colbert | 72¢ | 10:47 PM | |
| Reality Competition Program | The Traitors | 94¢ | 10:05 PM | |
| Lead Actor, Drama | Noah Wyle (The Pitt) | 95¢ | 10:05 PM | |
| Lead Actress, Drama | Rhea Seehorn (Pluribus) | 88¢ | 10:04 PM | |
| Supporting Actor, Drama | Tom Pelphrey (Task) | 48¢ | 10:09 PM | |
| Supporting Actress, Drama | Allison Janney | 5¢ | Katherine LaNasa, 80¢ | 10:03 PM |
| Directing, Drama | Slow Horses | 1¢ | Pluribus, 67¢ | 10:46 PM |
| Lead Actor, Comedy | Matthew Rhys (Widow's Bay) | 96¢ | 10:26 PM | |
| Lead Actress, Comedy | Jean Smart (Hacks) | 92¢ | 10:02 PM | |
| Supporting Actor, Comedy | Stephen Root (Widow's Bay) | 51¢ | 10:04 PM | |
| Supporting Actress, Comedy | Kate O'Flynn (Widow's Bay) | 87¢ | 10:02 PM | |
| Directing, Comedy | Hiro Murai (Widow's Bay) | 93¢ | 11:05 PM | |
| Writing, Comedy | Widow's Bay | 70¢ | 10:33 PM | |
| Lead Actor, Limited Or Movie | Matthew Rhys (The Beast in Me) | 25¢ | Oscar Isaac, 75¢ | 10:03 PM |
| Lead Actress, Limited Or Movie | Sally Field | 14¢ | Carey Mulligan, 38¢ | 10:26 PM |
The Creative Arts boards settled a week earlier, Monday, September 7, between 7:01 and 7:15 PM ET, with Antiques Roadshow following on Wednesday, September 9. Those grades, from the earlier editions of this page: on Saturday, September 5 the favorite paid on six of seven boards and Antiques Roadshow won Structured Reality from 27 cents; on Sunday, September 6 the leader at the cut paid once in five, with Ernest Harden Jr. winning guest actor in a drama from 10 cents, Rob Reiner beating Michael J. Fox, Betty Gilpin taking a coin flip from Kaitlin Olson, DTF St. Louis winning limited-series writing from 34 cents against Beef's 46, and Shailene Woodley the lone favorite to pay. Three weekend boards this page never tracked also settled to the favorite: David Harbour and Linda Cardellini, supporting actor and supporting actress for DTF St. Louis, and Remarkably Bright Creatures for Outstanding Movie. Across both ceremonies that is 33 settled boards, and the favorite at the cut paid on 24.
How These Numbers Were Made
Eight seats (Claude Fable, Claude Opus, Claude Sonnet, GPT, Gemini, GLM, Kimi and DeepSeek) priced the two series categories on August 1, every nominee plus the Tie line, from the same fetched card and no market prices, then read each other's anonymized reasoning and could revise once. The blend is the equal-weight mean of the revised round and it has not changed since. Every settled Kalshi contract on this page was pulled from the exchange's API at 12:51 AM ET on September 15, with the trade history on every row since Sunday night; the prices quoted for 8 PM ET are the last fills before the broadcast. Winners were checked against the Television Academy's list. These are model estimates, not predictions of fact and not financial advice. Our most-awards page tracks that board row by row, and every other market this panel has priced is on Kalshi Picks Today.
More on this: Oscars Best Picture 2027: The Model Verdict · White Lotus Season 4 Cast Odds · Big Brother 28 Winner: The Model Verdict · 2026 Ballon d'Or: The Model Verdict · Heisman Trophy 2026: The Model Verdict · Kalshi Picks Today: Every Scored Market
The Bottom Line
The question in the title has its answer, and the market gave it on August 1: The Pitt, and Widow's Bay. The panel backed the incumbent in drama and was right; it backed the former champion in comedy and was wrong, because a first season the voters liked enough for 14 trophies is not something a nomination count can show. The lesson the night actually supports is narrower than either call. A favorite under 80 cents on a single-award board lost four times, three of those winners had traded under 15 cents all day, and the deepest of the four boards, drama directing, was the worst miss of all. When the boards reopen next July, that is the class of contract to treat as unpriced no matter how much has traded on it, and the two boards still open from this year, the count ladders and the most-awards contract, are the ones to watch settle.
Panel verdicts generated August 1, 2026, price-blind, with a revision round; panel numbers and Aug. 1 prices frozen as of that date. Settlements, results and the pre-broadcast prices from the Kalshi API on September 15, 2026, at 12:51 AM ET, with trade history on every row from September 13 at 8 PM ET; the show-count ladders and the most-awards board were still open at that time with December 31, 2026 and December 31, 2027 expirations. Creative Arts grades carried from the September 6 to 8 editions of this page. Panel: Claude Fable, Claude Opus, Claude Sonnet, GPT, Gemini, GLM, Kimi and DeepSeek.
