By Jake Hari. Prices are last trades as of November 19, 2026. Panel verdicts were generated August 22, price-blind, from the 2028 Senate map, the locked 2024 carryover, presidential-year base rates back to 1980 and the 2026 midterm environment.
Kalshi traders make Democrats the favorite to control the Senate after the 2028 election, with the last trade at 88 cents on the dollar, up from 87 when this page was last updated on November 16 and up from 54 before the midterm. The number that moved it was the one every model named: the November 3 midterm, which by the Associated Press's calls flipped nine Republican-held Senate seats to Democrats, the ninth of them Alaska, called on November 17. Eight AI models that priced the same map in August without seeing the market ended at a coin flip after reading each other's reasoning, with a median of 51.
The market's read now sits 21 cents above its price on a Democrat winning the White House on the same election night, which last traded at 67 cents; on November 16 it was 20 cents above, and on October 26 it sat six cents under. The panel said those are two different bets, and the reason starts with which seats are actually on the 2028 ballot, a count the midterm just rewrote.
Which Seats Are Actually On The 2028 Ballot?
Nearly two thirds of this market was settled before a single 2028 ballot was printed. Of the 100 senators seated in January 2029:
- 33 Seats Are Already Locked From 2024. They were filled in 2024 and are not up again until 2030. That group splits 19 to 14 for Democrats, counting the two independents who caucus with them.
- 33 Regular Seats Were On The November 3 Ballot, in the 2026 midterms, which we scored seat by seat on the 2026 balance-of-power board. Counting the AP's race calls (AP via PBS NewsHour on election night, CNBC for Mississippi), Democrats won 21 of them and Republicans 12. The last two calls were Scott Colom's win in Mississippi on November 11 and Mary Peltola's in Alaska on November 17 (Alaska Public Media).
- 34 Seats Are On The Ballot In November 2028. This is the group the models spent their reasoning on. It now splits 18 Republican-held to 16 Democratic-held, because Sherrod Brown won the Ohio special election on November 3 and takes a seat that counted as Republican when the panel priced this.
That leaves the 34 seats on the 2028 ballot as the only ones still to be decided. Democrats, with 40 seats already locked for 2029, need 11 of them for an outright majority, or 10 plus the vice presidency, and they go into that election holding 16 of the 34, one of them now Ohio, where Brown faces voters again in 2028. Republicans, with 26 locked, need 25, or 24 plus the vice presidency, which means holding all 18 of their own 2028 seats and flipping seven Democratic ones. When the panel priced this in August, with the midterm still ahead, Democrats needed 32 of 67 and Republicans 37.
A tied Senate is run by the vice president's party, so whichever party wins the White House in 2028 can hold the chamber with 50 seats. That is the only mechanical thread tying this market to the presidential race, and it is worth exactly one seat. The bigger link is correlation, and the panel splits on which way it cuts.
Two of the 34 seats had appointed senators in them: Marco Rubio left Florida's to become Secretary of State, and JD Vance left Ohio's to become vice president. Both got special elections on November 3, 2026 for the rest of the current term: Ashley Moody held Florida's for Republicans, and Brown took Ohio's from Jon Husted for Democrats. Both seats return to the regular cycle in 2028.
These are market prices and estimates, not predictions of fact and not financial advice.
Why Won't The Panel Follow The Price?
Most of the models moved toward Republicans after reading each other, and nearly all of them moved for the same reason. The 2028 class was, when they priced it in August, usually described as 19 Republican-held seats and 15 Democratic-held, counting Florida and Ohio, which sounds like Republicans have more to defend. Count the seats whose incumbent won with less than 54% of the vote in 2022 and five of them sit on the Democratic side: Nevada, Pennsylvania, Arizona, Georgia and New Hampshire. Only Wisconsin and North Carolina are both in that range and genuinely open for Republicans, though each of those two was individually tighter than every Democratic seat but Nevada.
Utah and Alaska look close on paper too, but Mike Lee's opponent was an independent with no Democrat on the ballot, and Lisa Murkowski beat a fellow Republican in a ranked-choice count. A low winning share in a safe Republican state is no opening for Democrats, which is why the panel counted two live Republican targets rather than four. Opus, the most Republican-leaning model on the board, put the exposure in one line:
The decisive fact is exposure reversal: Democrats defend five sub-54% seats (NV 48.8, PA 51.2, AZ 51.4, GA 51.4, NH 53.5) against only two marginal R seats (WI 50.4, NC 50.5). — Opus
Sonnet gave Democrats a modest gain in the midterm and still found that Republicans reach a majority by simply holding every seat they already have in the 2028 group:
Republicans only need Class 3 to hold serve (net zero) to reach 51; Democrats need a net +2 swing, and the marginal-seat map doesn't clearly hand them that. — Sonnet
That arithmetic assumed the 2026 midterm would leave Republicans near 51 seats. It did not; holding serve in 2028 now leaves them at 44. The quote stands as what the panel reasoned on August 22, which is what this page grades.
The seat almost every model named first is Nevada, where Catherine Cortez Masto's 2022 win was the narrowest of anyone on the 2028 ballot, with John Fetterman, Mark Kelly and Raphael Warnock the next-closest Democrats. Those four states are also presidential battlegrounds, which is exactly why the models split. Kimi described the fork directly:
Nationalization cuts both ways: a Democratic presidential win protects those very swing-state seats and exposes WI/NC; a Republican win flips NV and likely more. — Kimi
That explains why the two contracts move together, but it does not explain why they cost about the same in August. Opus put a Democratic Senate at 42.5, well under where the market priced a Democratic presidency, because winning the White House still left the party holding every thin seat and then flipping one more.
Presidential years also rarely move the Senate much; the base rates the models were given put the median swing since 1980 at 3 seats. Only two elections broke that pattern: Reagan's landslide, which flipped 12 seats, and 2008, when a financial crisis broke weeks before the vote. No model could name a comparable condition two years out, so none of them priced one.
Stay ahead of the markets.
Daily insights and expert picks on Kalshi, Polymarket, and what's moving markets.
Free forever. Unsubscribe anytime.
The Board
The table sets the last trade and the book on each side against the median of the eight models, a number that has not changed since August 22.
| Outcome | Last trade | Book (bid / ask) | AI panel (median) | Gap |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Democratic Majority | 88¢ · Nov 19 | 88¢ / 89¢ | 51.0% | Market +37.0 |
| Republican Majority | 12¢ · Nov 19 | 10¢ / 12¢ | 49.0% | Panel +37.0 |
Prices are the most recent trades as of November 19, 2026; the panel figure is the median of the eight models, so one outlier cannot drag it. At 8:45 a.m. Eastern on Thursday the two last trades summed to 100, 88 on the Democratic side and 12 on the Republican, though the two books put the midpoints at 88.5 and 11: the Democratic side's last print was a single contract sold at 88 at 8:39:06 a.m., and the Republican side's was 102 contracts bought at 12 at 8:00:58 a.m., the only trade at 12 since the November 16 update. The Democratic side was quoted 88 bid against 89 asked, with about 10 contracts on the bid and 600 on the offer, 11,510 more at 90 behind it; the Republican side was 10 bid against 12 asked, about 1,520 on the bid and 2,600 on the offer, with 9,910 behind it at 13. The gap column reads 37 points on the Democratic side, one wider than on November 16, and 37 on the Republican, two narrower. The panel priced this on August 22; on September 10, the first time this page recorded the 2026 board, traders still made Republicans 53-cent favorites to hold the Senate in 2026. That board settled Yes for Democrats at 12:46 a.m. Eastern on November 4, and the gap is the price of that input, which most models said would move them, not a fresh argument about 2028.
The top line moved a cent for the third update running, this time up and in three days, on the quietest stretch this page has recorded since the midterm. The Democratic side last traded at 87 when this page was updated on November 16, printed 86 on Monday afternoon, 67 contracts of it in one trade, 89 four times on 18 contracts in all, and 87 or 88 on everything else; the Republican side traded 10 and 11 until Thursday morning's 12. About 2,015 contracts traded across the two sides since the last update, 1,660 on the Democratic side and 355 on the Republican, against about 24,700 in the six days before that and 67,800 in the six before those, so the market has traded about 228,000 contracts in all and these three days are less than one percent of it. The book has rebuilt under the price: the 820 contracts that sat on the 87 bid on November 16 are now 15,860 one cent below the price at 87, with 10,460 at 86 under them, and 11,510 are offered at 90 where 51 sat three days ago; the 10,500-contract wall at 93 is down to six contracts, with 11,600 at 95 and 81,550 at 96 behind it. On the Republican side the 35,180 contracts that were bid at 8 are down to 10,800, 1,520 are bid at 10 and 1,080 at 9, and the offers sit at 12, 13 and 14, about 2,600, 9,910 and 11,900, where 28 were offered at 11 on November 16. Open interest went from about 32,430 to about 32,410 contracts on the Democratic side and from about 33,860 to about 33,730 on the Republican.
The cross-check that matters is Kalshi's combined market on the presidency, House and Senate together, which has traded about 595,000 contracts. Its summed book on the four Democratic-Senate scenarios is 84.4 bid to 88.0 asked, a midpoint of about 86.2, a little over two cents under this board's own midpoint of 88.5; on November 16 the midpoint sat a little over one under, and on October 26 the two boards agreed to the cent. The four last trades sum to about 86.4, inside that spread. The combined market is thinner per leg than this board, so its midpoint is a soft number, and this board's midpoint sits just above the four-leg spread again, as it did on November 10.
What Moved Since November 16
The Senate map for 2027 is finished, and the market treated the last piece as already in the price. Alaska's Division of Elections posted its Tuesday count on November 17 with Mary Peltola at 50.1% of first-choice votes, a majority that made the ranked-choice tabulation scheduled for Wednesday unnecessary in the Senate race, and the Associated Press called the seat for her that evening, Alaska time (Alaska Public Media). Wednesday's tabulation ran for the legislative races on 290,323 ballots, Dan Sullivan had not conceded as of that morning, and the state plans to certify on November 25 (Anchorage Daily News); his campaign had said on Monday that it would let the count "run its course until every legal vote is counted and certified" (Democracy Docket). The Alaska Bureau of Investigation and the Justice Department both said this week that their investigations into the race continue, and the Trump administration's civil suit seeking to segregate ballots and delay certification, dismissed before the election, is on appeal at the Ninth Circuit with briefs due January 11 (Anchorage Daily News). It is the ninth Republican-held seat to flip counting Ohio's special, which sits in the 2028 group, and the eighth in the midterm class, which now reads 21 Democrats to 12 Republicans; the arithmetic above reads 34 seats to decide instead of 35, with Democrats needing 11 of them instead of 12.
The trade records show the call landing on a market that had nothing left to do with it. The Republican side's one sizable trade of the week, 231 contracts sold at 10 at 5:31:56 p.m. Eastern on Tuesday, came hours before Alaska posted its count, and the side then traded a single contract until Thursday morning's 102 bought at 12; the Democratic side's two Tuesday-evening trades, 25 and 28 contracts sold at 87, were at the price it had been printing since Monday. Wednesday was the only day with any size, about 1,210 contracts on the Democratic side, and sellers outweighed buyers about 1,280 to 380 on that side since the update and 240 to 115 on the Republican, yet the side closes a cent higher than it did. The one I keep coming back to is the bid at 87: Wednesday's sellers hit it all day and never printed below it, and by Thursday morning 15,860 contracts rested there, where 820 sat on November 16.
The neighboring boards barely moved. The presidential party board, this page's benchmark, last traded at 67 for Democrats, as it did on November 16, so the Senate board sits 21 cents above it, one more than then, on its own one-cent move. The 2028 House board went from 80 to 81 for Democrats, quoted 80 against 81. The combined presidency-House-Senate market widened its discount to this board from a little over one cent to a little over two, which the cross-check above covers. The switch record below did not move either: no new word from Fetterman or Murkowski, and the D.C. Circuit had not issued a decision in the Kelly case as of this update, six months after it heard argument. The panel's eight numbers stay August's; they are not re-run on a price or a race call, and the table below says so.
What Moved From November 10 To November 16
Both pieces of news that week favored Democrats, and the price fell a cent anyway. The Associated Press called Mississippi for Scott Colom on Wednesday, November 11, and Cindy Hyde-Smith conceded by phone that afternoon, saying "while this is not the outcome we worked for or hoped for, I respect the decision of Mississippi voters" (WAPT); it was the eighth Republican-held seat to flip and put Democrats at 55 seats or more in the new Senate (CNBC). Alaska was the last Senate race in the country uncalled, and its count moved one way that week: Mary Peltola led Dan Sullivan by 4,250 first-choice votes, 118,926 to 114,676, on Tuesday's update with more than 245,000 ballots counted (Anchorage Daily News), held 49.9% to 46% on Friday's with the AP estimating 96% of ballots counted (Alaska Public Media), and crossed the line on Saturday's, 50.1% to 46.1% with more than 283,000 ballots tallied and thousands still to count (Anchorage Daily News via Yahoo). A first-choice majority that held through the November 18 tabulation would end the race without a ranked-choice round, and the November 17 count did. At that update the arithmetic read 35 seats to decide instead of 36, and Democrats needed 12 of them instead of 13. The market did not react to either headline because it had already priced both: each seat had leaned Democratic in every count this page has recorded since November 4.
The one real move came before either headline, late on the night of the update. At 11:56:51 p.m. Eastern on Tuesday, November 10, a buyer took 1,556 contracts of the Democratic side at 89 and 90 in 17 fills, 800 of them in one fill at 90, and 304 more at 90 and 91 over the next 32 seconds, the first prints above 90 since this page's November 4 update; five seconds after the first batch, a seller hit the Republican bids with 1,918 contracts at 10, then a single fill of 5,000 at 9 at 11:57:11 p.m., the largest one-fill sale on the Republican side since election night, and 620 at 8 at 11:58:04, below the 10-to-15 range the side had held since November 4. At 7:10:43 a.m. Wednesday a buyer took 4,279 Republican contracts back at 10 and 11, 4,276 of them in one fill at 11, the largest single fill a buyer has initiated on the Republican side in this page's records; the 1,694-contract election-night buy went in four fills. Tuesday night and Wednesday did about 12,900 of the 15,270 Republican-side contracts traded since the update, and the Democratic side printed 92 six times between 12:02 a.m. and 5:46 a.m. Wednesday, never more than 53 contracts at a time, and did not print above 91 again before the November 16 update.
The rest of the week sold the Democratic side back down in small pieces: 791 contracts hit the 87 bid in two fills at 2:42 a.m. Friday, the largest sale on the Democratic side in the six days, 82 went at 86 at 9:23 a.m. Saturday, the only print below 87 since the update, and the 111 sold at 88 and 87 at 8:13 a.m. Monday set the 87 that update recorded. Sellers outweighed buyers on both contracts over those six days, about 5,080 to 4,360 on the Democratic side and 8,550 to 6,720 on the Republican; the Democratic side finished a cent lower than it started and the Republican side two.
The boards around this one moved a cent each that week. The presidential party board, this page's benchmark, went from 66 to 67 for Democrats, so the Senate board then sat 20 cents above it, two fewer than on November 10. The 2028 House board moved with it, a last trade of 80 at that update against 79 the week before, quoted 80 against 81. The combined presidency-House-Senate market, which had sat a little over two cents under this board on November 10, was a little over one under on November 16. Nothing changed on the three senators below that week either, and a week whose biggest trade was a 5,000-contract sale at 9 cents gave the panel no reason to re-price.
What Moved From November 4 To November 10
One cent net in six days: up two on Wednesday evening, back one over the weekend, and the rest was a market absorbing size between 86 and 90. The Democratic side was 87 at the November 4 update, printed 89 at 5:48 p.m. that day, and at 7:25:11 p.m. a buyer took 2,785 contracts in 18 fills at 89 and 90, 818 of them at 89 in one fill, the first 90 since the update. Another 1,103 contracts were bought at 90 at 10:25 p.m., and the side closed Wednesday at 89 on about 7,900 contracts after the update, three quarters of it bought. It did not print above 90 or below 86 again before the November 10 update, and the Republican side stayed between 10 and 15; its first 11 since the update printed at 7:25 p.m. Wednesday, in the same second as the big Democratic buy.
Thursday was the busiest day since Wednesday, about 23,150 contracts on the Democratic side and 17,850 on the Republican, and it ran in matched pairs. At 5:19:08 a.m. a seller hit the Republican bids with 6,256 contracts in 11 fills at 14 and 13, 4,000 of them in one fill at 13, and 18 seconds later a buyer took 4,071 contracts of the Democratic side at 87 in five fills, 1,831 and 1,000 of them in single prints; the two sides were being traded the same direction inside one minute. At 9:07:13 a.m. a single fill of 2,400 contracts sold at 87. At 11:58:36 a.m. a buyer took 4,358 contracts at 88 in seven fills, 3,474 of them in one, the largest Democratic-side fill since the 4,935-contract print of election night; at 12:01:32 p.m. another 1,377 went at 89. At 4:40:10 p.m. a seller hit the 88 bid with 2,785 contracts in three fills, the same quantity to the hundredth of a contract that the Wednesday-evening buyer had taken at 89 and 90, and one of those three fills, 1,377 contracts, was the exact size of the 12:01 p.m. buy at 89. Six minutes after that sale, at 4:46:16 p.m., 5,887 contracts of the Republican side were sold at 10 in four fills, 4,473 of them in one, the largest single Republican fill since election night. The trade records do not say whether the matched sizes were one participant closing out; they say the sizes matched and that the Democratic side closed Thursday where it opened, at 89. Friday did about 3,380 contracts on the Democratic side, 2,810 of them bought, and 228 on the Republican, and the side closed at 88 before the 89 print early Saturday. Across those three days, buyers took about 21,360 contracts of the Democratic side against 13,080 sold, and sellers hit the Republican side with about 14,010 contracts against 5,550 bought.
The weekend sold the top of the range without testing the bottom. From Saturday morning through Tuesday's update the Democratic side traded about 10,480 contracts, 8,830 of them sold, and never left 87 to 89. The biggest print was a single fill of 2,996 contracts sold at 87 at 7:22:18 p.m. Saturday, the largest one-fill sale on the side since election night; the 3,261 contracts sold on Wednesday morning went in a batch of fills down to 68, this one went at one price and the side printed 88 again 45 minutes later. Another 1,119 contracts had been sold at 88 in three fills at 3:49 p.m. that afternoon, 900 of them in one, and 1,119 more went at 87 in one fill at 5:14 p.m. Sunday. The buyers were small: the largest was 327 contracts at 89 at 12:42 p.m. Monday. The Republican side told the same story from the other contract, about 2,530 contracts bought against 770 sold, led by 1,177 bought at 12 in two fills at noon Saturday, and it closed Saturday at 11 and Sunday and Monday at 12. The volume fell every day: about 5,930 Democratic-side contracts on Saturday, 3,280 on Sunday, 1,150 on Monday and 140 in the first hours of Tuesday, which is a market that has found its price rather than one still looking for it.
The two seats that still count moved toward Democrats without being called. Alaska's Monday update put Mary Peltola at 106,321 first-choice votes to Dan Sullivan's 103,804, 48.6% to 47.5%, a lead of 2,517 that had been 637 on the count posted the Wednesday after the election; the count passed 220,000 ballots, about 5,000 more than the November 4 update, with more results due Tuesday and Friday (Anchorage Daily News). If neither finishes above 50% of first-choice votes, the ranked-choice tabulation that decides it runs November 18, with certification expected November 25 (Alaska Public Media). In Mississippi, Scott Colom's lead over Cindy Hyde-Smith stood at 2,574 votes on Monday with 97% of the vote in; mail absentees postmarked by election day had to arrive by Tuesday, November 10, voters had until 5 p.m. that day to cure affidavit ballots, the counties must certify by November 13, Mississippi has no recount law, and Hyde-Smith's lawyers have demanded that officials separate and preserve every affidavit ballot (Yahoo News). Neither seat changed the arithmetic above until it was called, and neither changes the majority Democrats have already won for 2027; what they decide is which end of the Republican range in that arithmetic applies in 2028.
The boards around this one barely moved. The presidential party board, this page's benchmark, went from 67 to 66 for Democrats, so the Senate board then sat 22 cents above it, two more than on November 4. The 2028 House board, which the panel has not priced, went from 78 bid against 81 asked to a last trade of 79, quoted 79 against 80. The combined presidency-House-Senate market, which sat seven cents under this board on the midpoint of its summed book on November 4, was a little over two under at that update. The switch record did not change: Fetterman's answer is still the September one quoted below, Murkowski has said nothing new, and the D.C. Circuit had not ruled in the Kelly case when that update went up. The eight numbers in the table below are still August's, and nothing in these six days asked them to change.
What Moved From October 26 To November 4
Democrats took the Senate, the Associated Press called it shortly before midnight on Tuesday (AP via PBS NewsHour, published 11:40 p.m. Eastern), and this board went from 54 to 87. By the AP's count Democrats flipped seven Republican-held seats, Texas, North Carolina, Ohio, Iowa, Kansas, Maine and South Carolina, and held Georgia, New Hampshire and Michigan, for at least 54 seats (CBS News). Two seats were still open at the November 4 update. In Alaska, Mary Peltola led Dan Sullivan by 626 votes of 213,873 counted at 3 a.m. Wednesday (Alaska Beacon), with the ranked-choice tabulation scheduled for November 18 (Alaska Public Media). In Mississippi, Scott Colom led Cindy Hyde-Smith by 43 votes at 2 a.m. Wednesday, with 97% of precincts reporting and thousands of affidavit ballots still to count (Magnolia Tribune). The 33 cents came in three legs: ten of them on October 29, five on election eve, and the rest after the polls closed on Tuesday. The Democratic side was 54 at the October 26 update; it closed at 64 on Thursday, October 29, at 69 on election eve, traded 70 to 73 through the 7 and 8 o'clock hours on election night, and printed as high as 93 before 1 a.m. on Wednesday. The board next door, Kalshi's 2026 Senate market, closed at 11:46 p.m. and settled Yes for Democrats at 12:46 a.m. on November 4 under its media-consensus rule, on 19.3 million contracts traded on its Democratic side on election day alone.
The first leg came before a vote was counted. At 4:36:42 p.m. Eastern on Thursday, October 29, a buyer took 6,093 contracts of the Democratic side in a single second, in 16 fills at 54 and 55, seven times the 842-contract buy of September 22 that had been this market's record, then 369 more at 59 six seconds later; at 5:47 p.m. another 1,200 went at 62 to 64, and the side closed the day at 64. The Republican side was sold in the same minutes: 369 at 44 in two fills at 4:36:48, 1,395 at 44 in four fills at 4:47:32, 1,000 at 41 at 4:48:09, and 678 at 40 at 5:47. I cannot tie the buy to a headline; the 2026 board was at 67 to 68 that afternoon, four cents above the October 26 stamp. Eight hours later, at 12:47 a.m. Friday, 2,933 contracts of the Democratic side sold at 61 and 62 in nine fills, and the side closed Friday at 59 and Saturday at 61.
The second leg came on election eve. At 10:29:52 a.m. on Monday, November 2, 2,542 contracts were bought from 61 to 64 in seven fills, 1,000 of them at 62, and in that second and the next 12, 3,495 contracts of the Republican side were sold at 38 and 34; the Democratic side closed Monday at 69 and the Republican at 34. The final New York Times/Siena polls, released the day before, had Democrats ahead in all seven toss-up Senate races (Siena College Research Institute), and the 2026 board closed Monday at 76. Election day itself brought a dip before the polls closed: at 1:52:02 p.m. Tuesday a seller hit the Democratic bids with 912 contracts in 20 fills in one second, from 68 down to 61, six seconds after 1,200 contracts of the Republican side had been sold at 27, so for six seconds someone was selling both sides of this board, while the 2026 board slipped from 77 to 72 over the morning and early afternoon with no headline I can tie it to. The next Democratic print was 72, at 5:00 p.m.
Election night started slowly here and fast next door. The 2026 board went from 75 to 88 between 6 and 7 p.m. on 1.4 million contracts and was 98 by 9 p.m.; this board traded 70 to 73 until 9:00:27 p.m., when a buyer took 1,571 contracts at 72 to 75, 1,000 of them at 75. It was 80 by 9:50 and 84 by 11:48, and in the ten minutes before midnight 4,707 contracts traded between 79 and 91, including 2,996 bought at 11:57:39 from 82 to 91 in 32 fills. At 12:14:51 a.m. a buyer paid 88 to 92 for 3,057 contracts, 2,534 of them at 92 in one fill; the side printed 93 for the first time at 12:44:48 and 535 contracts went at that price at 12:49:55. At 1:01:49 a.m. a single fill of 4,935 contracts printed at 90, the largest single trade on the Democratic side in this market's history, nearly six times the September 22 record.
Eleven minutes later the thin book this page has described since August got its test. At 1:12:59 a.m. a seller hit the bids with 5,261 contracts in 30 fills in a single second, from 88 down to 66: 1,000 printed at 86 and 1,000 at 83 among the fills above 80, then the ladder gave way, 139 at 73 in two fills, 48 at 71, 55 at 68 in two fills, 525 at 67 twice and 1,267 at 66, and the size-weighted price of the batch was about 76. The side traded 88 again within a minute, when 161 contracts were bought there at 1:13:58, a 1,206-contract buy at 1:26:48 put about 1,100 of them through at 89, and the hour closed at 86. A second sweep came after the morning open. At 10:00:43 a.m. Wednesday a seller cleared 3,261 contracts from 83 down to 68 in 23 fills, 1,000 of them at 80, then 309 at 72, 250 at 70, 525 at 69 twice and 139 at 68, the same quantity to the hundredth of a contract that a buyer had taken at 90 in 14 fills at 9:04:05 a.m., 56 minutes earlier. The trade records do not say whether that was one participant closing what it had just bought; they say the sizes matched, 3,260.5 contracts each, and that the low it cleared was two cents above the overnight one. The side was back at 85 by 10:48 and 86 by 10:49. Between them the two sweeps account for every print below 79 since the polls closed, bar a hundredth of a contract that printed at 77 at 10:05 a.m., and a 525-contract bid filled twice at 67 overnight and twice more at 69 in the morning, the same size reposted.
The Republican side told the same story in bigger pieces. At 10:08:18 p.m. on election night a buyer took 1,694 contracts of it at 22 cents, in four fills, with 168 sold in the same second. At 10:57:21 p.m., 12,956 contracts of the Republican side were sold at 22 in five fills in one second, 7,880 of them in a single fill, a print 13 times larger than the 969-contract sale of October 22 that had been that side's record, and more than 40 minutes before the AP story went out. The side first printed 12 at 11:58:32 p.m., 10 at 12:23 a.m., and the largest print since was 2,230 contracts sold at 11 at 4:50:19 a.m.; it has been quoted 12 bid against 13 asked through most of Wednesday. Across the two sides, Wednesday was the busiest day in the board's history by 3:40 p.m., about 60,800 contracts on the Democratic side and 11,700 on the Republican, with Democratic buyers taking about 38,200 of the Democratic side's total against about 22,600 sold.
The boards around this one moved with it. The presidential party board, this page's benchmark, went from 60 at the October 26 stamp to 61 at Monday's close, printed 75 between 10 and 11 p.m. on election night and 56 in the last hour before midnight, on about 40,300 contracts for the day against a few hundred to a couple of thousand on the days before, and traded 66 bid against 67 asked at the November 4 update. The Senate board then sat above the presidency board by 20 cents; on October 26 it was six under, and in every earlier edition of this page it was under or level. The 2026 House board settled Yes for Democrats at 1:02 a.m. Wednesday, 16 minutes after the Senate board, and the 2028 House board, which the panel has not priced, traded 78 bid against 81 asked for Democrats. The combined presidency-House-Senate market, which agreed with this board to the cent on October 26, summed to about 78.5 on the last trades of its four Democratic-Senate legs at the November 4 update, with a book midpoint of about 80.
The switch record did not change, but its weight did: with Democrats at 54 seats or more, one senator changing sides no longer decides the chamber for the next two years, and a Philadelphia Inquirer headline on Wednesday said his critics call the new majority "Fetterman proofed" (Inquirer). Fetterman's standing answer is still the September one quoted below, and the seats he and Murkowski hold are on the 2028 ballot, which is what this page prices. No ruling in Mark Kelly's appeal had been reported as of November 4. The panel numbers below did not move; they were generated on August 22 and are not re-scored by a price. What changed is that the condition most of them named as the thing that would move them most has happened, at the far end of the range they drew, and the section after the table says what each of them said it would do about it.
What Moved From October 23 To October 26
One cent on this board, and three on the one next door. The 2028 Democratic contract printed exactly twice between the two updates, both times at 54: 194 contracts at 11:10 p.m. Eastern on Friday, October 23, the third-largest fill in the contract's history at the time, and 27 contracts at 7:58 p.m. on Sunday. The Friday buy landed in the same clock minute as the 179-contract buy of Tuesday, October 13, ten days earlier to the minute, with the seconds hand one tick off: 11:10:40 on the 13th, 11:10:41 on the 23rd. Nothing in the trade records says whether the two buys came from the same participant; only the minute matched. The offer at 54 that has absorbed every Democratic buyer since October 13 shrank from about 4,860 contracts to about 3,330, and only 221 of that went to buyers, so roughly 1,300 of it was pulled rather than filled. The bid underneath it grew the other way, from about 2,660 contracts at 53 to about 4,810, and an offer the exact size of Friday night's fill, 194 contracts, sat at 56 on October 26. The book did not say whose it was.
The Republican side is the one that moved, and it moved on buyers. On Saturday afternoon 86 contracts were bought at 45, two more at 4:56 p.m., then 53 at 45 at 1:11 p.m. on Sunday in two fills in the same second, 11 and 42. A 53-contract sale at 44 followed at 8:32 p.m. Sunday, and at 8:56 a.m. on Monday a buyer took 128 at 45 in two fills of 64 in the same second, which is where the Republican last trade sat on October 26. Buyers paid 45 for 269 contracts against one 53-contract sale at 44, and the price is a cent higher for it. The 135-contract offer at 45 that was the last thin spot in this book on Friday has been replaced by about 3,230 contracts at the same price; the 731 at 46, the 300 at 47 and the 1,000 at 48 are gone, with 1,300 then offered at 47, a new 1,000-contract bid at 43, and the 44 bid grew from about 3,090 to about 3,720. Open interest went from about 1,330 to about 1,550 contracts on the Democratic side and from about 2,190 to about 2,330 on the Republican.
The 2026 Senate board, the number that moved this page most, gave back most of its October climb. It stood at 66 cents for Democrats at the October 23 update, closed that Friday at 67, Saturday at 64 and Sunday at 63, printed 62 on Sunday afternoon and again overnight, and traded 63 bid against 64 asked at the October 26 update, six cents under what was then that market's record close, 69, set on Thursday, October 22. About 1.2 million contracts traded across its two sides in three days. After the 103,000-contract hour between 1 and 2 p.m. Friday, which the section below covers, the biggest hours were between 2 and 3 a.m. Sunday, about 53,000 contracts that closed the hour at 63, between 3 and 4 p.m. Sunday, about 49,000, and between 9 and 10 a.m. Saturday, about 40,000. No headline that afternoon explains the slide. The polling news ran the other way: RealClearPolling's averages, as written up on Saturday afternoon, had Democrats ahead in Texas, Ohio, Maine, North Carolina and Alaska, every one a Republican-held seat, and the board fell through them. The 2026 House board went from 91 to 90, and the presidential party board, this page's benchmark, closed Saturday at 60 on about 7,000 contracts, its busiest day since at least October 7, where the daily history pulled for this edition begins, gave the cent back on Sunday and traded 60 again on the morning of October 26.
The switch record added one small item. On October 24 a former Republican state representative from Pennsylvania, Matthew Dowling, published an open letter inviting Fetterman to join his party (Tampa Free Press); Fetterman's office did not immediately respond to the appeal, and his standing answer is the September one quoted below. The next print on the Democratic side after the letter was Sunday's 27-contract buy at 54. The panel numbers below did not move; this board moved a cent in three days, and the one next door moved three.
What Moved From October 8 To October 23
By October 23 the Democratic side was two cents cheaper and the Republican side a cent dearer, and for once the move came from orders on this board rather than the one next door. At 12:07 a.m. Eastern on Tuesday, October 13, a buyer took 171 contracts of the Democratic side in a single second, 100 at 57 and 71 at 56, the first print at 57 in two weeks and the largest at that price since the September 22 buy. By that evening someone was offering at 54, two cents under what buyers had been paying, and at 11:10 p.m. the same day, 23 hours after the batch, a buyer lifted 179 contracts there. That offer absorbed every Democratic buyer through 12:51 p.m. on October 23, including that one, 12 fills and about 506 contracts, and was quoted that afternoon with about 4,860 contracts behind it. The 1,000-contract bid at 50 and the 1,000-contract offer at 57 that framed this book for a month were gone; 1,200 sat bid at 51 and 1,100 offered at 55. Whether the offer at 54 and the bid at 44 on the other contract belonged to one hand or two, they said the same thing: there was size against a Democratic Senate in the mid-50s.
The Republican side went up first and then down. Buyers paid 48 for about 250 contracts between October 14 and October 20, including 183 bought at 48 on the afternoon of Sunday, October 18, about 40 minutes after the same quantity had sold at 47. Then, at 11:29 p.m. on Thursday, October 22, a seller hit the 46-cent bid with 29 fills in 24 seconds, 969 contracts in all. The 842-contract Democratic buy of September 22 was, as of that update, still the largest single fill in this market's history, and its minute, about 852 contracts, still the busiest; this sale was bigger in total but came in pieces, the largest of them 168 contracts, the last of which printed in the next clock minute. An hour later 27 contracts were bought at 44, which is where the Republican last trade sat on October 23, and the book re-formed at 44 bid against 45 asked, with about 3,090 contracts on the bid. Nothing in the news that day accounts for the sale. The 2026 Senate board next door had closed at 69 cents for Democrats that evening, its highest close to that point, so whoever sold the 2028 Republican contract was selling with the tide, not against it.
One thing in the switch record changed. On October 10, asked at Joint Base Andrews whether he had talked to John Fetterman about becoming a Republican, President Trump said, "I'd love to see him as a Republican. He does better as a Republican than he does as a Democrat" (AP via WKMG). A representative for Fetterman did not immediately respond to the AP; the September answer quoted below still stood. The next print on the Democratic side after the remark came two nights later, and it was the 171-contract buy at 56 and 57.
Open interest on the Democratic contract went from 623 to about 1,330 contracts and on the Republican side from 1,175 to about 2,190. The 2026 Senate board, the number that moved this page most, spent the fortnight on a dip and then a climb it had only partly given back by October 23: 62 cents for Democrats at the October 8 update, 60 on October 9 and 10, 65 at the close of October 20, 69 at the close of October 22, the highest close in that market's history to that point, and 66 at the October 23 update after a 103,000-contract hour between 1 and 2 p.m. that Friday. The climb began the day before Cook Political Report published polls, fielded October 9 to 13, that put Democrats ahead in the Iowa, Ohio and Texas Senate races, and Friday's three-cent drop came with no headline I can find. The 2026 House board went from 90 to 91, and the presidential party board, which this page uses as its benchmark, was unchanged at 59. The September 22 buy described next was still this market's largest single fill at that update, and the panel numbers after it did not move.
What Moved From September 10 To October 8
The number that moved most between September 10 and October 8 was not on this board. On September 10 Kalshi's 2026 Senate market made Republicans 53-cent favorites to hold the chamber in November. Democrats overtook them on September 14, at 52 to 48 by Kalshi's own count, on a day that traded more than 206,000 contracts, and kept climbing: 63 cents at the close of September 22, a high of 66 the next day, and 61 bid against 62 asked at the October 8 update, with the last trade at 62. The 2026 House board moved from 86 to 90 cents for Democrats over the same stretch, and the presidential party board, which this page uses as its benchmark, went from 58 to 59.
The 2028 board answered on the evening of Tuesday, September 22. At 8:41 p.m. Eastern a buyer took 842 contracts of the Democratic side at 57 cents and 10 at 56 in the same minute, the largest fill in this market's history to that point by a factor of two; the previous record was the 419-contract Republican buy on August 24. Two minutes later 639 contracts sold at 56. Open interest, which had sat at 79 contracts since September 3, closed the night at 292. The next morning, at 11:17 a.m., sellers hit the thin bids all the way down to 50 cents, in the same minute two 5-lots at 57 and 56, 15 contracts at 51 and 73 at 50; at 4:56 p.m. another 10 went at 51 and 48 at 50, and between 4:59 and 5:01 p.m. buyers took 171 contracts back at 56. The day's range was 50 to 57 and it closed at 56. I cannot tie the 842-contract buy to a headline. What the trade records show is that it landed the same night the 2026 board was printing 63 for the first time, and that the direction matched.
Since then the Democratic side traded most days through October 4, in lots ranging from a few contracts to 43, nearly all of them buyers paying 56 or 57; a 10-lot sold at 50 and a 5-lot bought at 55 on September 26, and two five-contract sales at 51 and 52 on September 27, are the only prints below 56. The last trade before the October 8 update was 35 contracts at 56 on October 4, and nothing traded on either side in the four days between that print and the update. The Republican side has been quieter: 48 contracts bought at 50 cents on September 16, 43 sold at 43 on the evening of September 23, a 10-lot bought at 50 and a 10-lot sold at 43 two minutes apart on the morning of September 26 and a 4-lot bought at 49 that evening, 10 at 48 on September 30, and three sold at 43 on October 3, which is where the Republican last trade sat on October 8. Open interest on the Democratic contract went from 79 to 623 contracts; on the Republican side it went from 1,112 to 1,175. The 1,000-contract bid at 50 and the 1,000-contract offer at 57 that framed the book on September 10 were posted again at the same size on October 8; the 842-contract buy went off at that 57 offer, and 121 contracts traded into the 50 bid the next morning. What was new at that update was the depth far from the price: about 435,000 contracts rested on the Democratic contract, bids from 24 to 35 cents and offers from 73 cents up, none of it closer than 17 cents to the last trade. The board is deeper than it was and no easier to trade at the number it shows. The panel's numbers below did not move; they were generated before any of this and are not re-scored by a price.
Every Model's Number
Each model priced the market without seeing it. Round 1 is its first independent answer. Round 2 is after reading the other seven's reasoning, anonymized, with the freedom to revise or hold.
| Model | Round 1 (D) | Round 2 (D) | Moved |
|---|---|---|---|
| DeepSeek | 42.5% | 63.0% | +20.5 |
| Gemini | 65.0% | 54.0% | −11.0 |
| ChatGPT | 56.0% | 53.0% | −3.0 |
| GLM | 48.0% | 53.0% | +5.0 |
| Fable | 57.0% | 49.0% | −8.0 |
| Sonnet | 57.0% | 46.0% | −11.0 |
| Kimi | 55.0% | 44.0% | −11.0 |
| Opus | 44.0% | 42.5% | −1.5 |
| Panel Median | 55.5% | 51.0% | −4.5 |
Every model on this panel is graded against real market settlements — records to date: Gemini 88% on 17,233 graded calls · GLM 85% on 6,668 graded calls · Kimi 88% on 13,962 graded calls · DeepSeek 85% on 6,438 graded calls. Recomputed daily; the full scoreboard is public.
- Every number here gets graded in public once the market settles, on the full graded scoreboard.
More live boards from the same panel: 2026 Senate control, settled Yes for Democrats · 2026 House control, settled Yes for Democrats · 2028 presidential race, Democrats 67¢. Prices fetched November 19, 2026.
Where The Panel Changed Its Mind
The revision round moved this board more than most, and it moved away from the price. DeepSeek reversed itself completely after re-weighting the 2026 leg:
A D+6.3 generic ballot and −21.7% approval in a 2026 map that protects most Democratic incumbents produces a D net gain of 3, then a likely Democratic 2028 presidential win delivers the decisive seat in Wisconsin. — DeepSeek
[Editor's note: DeepSeek's path counts the Florida and Ohio special elections as 2026 gains, but both seats face voters again in 2028. Opus flagged the same point independently. We publish model reasoning verbatim, including where our own data card disagrees with it.]
Gemini went the other way after conceding the map problem it had underweighted, and Opus barely moved, holding the position the rest of the board drifted toward. In round one the panel sat within striking distance of the market. Reading each other pulled it to a coin flip.
Three Senators Who Could Change The Answer Without An Election
Senate control can also change because someone switches sides, and the two senators whose party loyalty has been most publicly questioned, plus a third facing a different kind of pressure, all sit in the class up in 2028.
Lisa Murkowski, the Alaska Republican, has said openly that she has considered joining the Senate Democratic caucus, calling it an "interesting hypothetical" and telling Semafor there is "some openness to exploring something different than the status quo." She has also said, on the GD Politics podcast, "I don't see the Democrats being much better," so this is an open question rather than a decision.
John Fetterman has spent two years denying he will leave the Democratic Party, even as talk of a switch has trailed him through his votes for Trump Cabinet nominees and his regular Fox News appearances. The loudest test yet came on September 9, when he appeared by recorded video at the Republican midterm convention in Dallas to introduce Pennsylvania's Republican senator, Dave McCormick, as "the kind of senator that gets the job done," and said in the video, "I'm always going to reject the extremes and socialism and the anti-American way of life" (NBC News). He answered the switch question the same day, in a statement: "I'm a lifelong Democrat who votes overwhelmingly with my party — and should the Senate flip in November, I will still be the 51st vote that I ran on" (AP via KSAT). Asked again on Capitol Hill on September 15, he told reporters, "I'm not going to be a Republican!" and "If I turn a Republican, then I'll be a liar" (NBC News). He has told Spotlight PA he would formally switch only if the party made opposition to Israel part of its official platform, and the Pennsylvania Working Families Party has said it will back a primary challenger against him in 2028. After the midterm, with Democrats at 56 seats, a switch would no longer decide the chamber for 2027 and 2028; the question this page prices is the seat he holds in 2028.
Mark Kelly's case is different in kind: nobody has questioned his party loyalty, but the Pentagon's review raised the possibility of recalling a sitting senator to active duty. In November 2025 the Pentagon opened a review of Kelly, a retired Navy captain, over a video in which he and five other Democratic lawmakers reminded service members of their duty to refuse illegal orders, and said it could recall him to active duty (CNN, NPR). Kelly called it an attempt to chill military dissent and sued Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth. In February 2026 a federal judge blocked the action, writing that the department had "trampled on Senator Kelly's First Amendment freedoms"; the government's appeal was argued before the D.C. Circuit in May 2026, and no ruling had been reported as of this update on November 19.
Every model was given the switch record as it stood on August 22, and most assigned it a small tail in both directions. None of them saw the Dallas video. Fable was blunt about the size of the effect: a formal switch by either Murkowski or Fetterman would move this market five to eight points on its own, which was more than the gap between the panel and the price when the panel priced it, and is now a fraction of the 37-point gap the midterm opened. The Dallas video is the closest anyone has come to testing that, and the first answer was a week of silence: not one contract traded on either side until September 16, when the first print was a 48-contract Republican buy at 50 cents, four above the previous Republican trade. The next move, six days later, was the 842-contract Democratic buy described above. If the video moved anyone, the trade records do not show it.
When Does This Market Actually Get Decided?
Mostly on November 3, 2026, when the midterms filled the 33 seats it had to fill that year, out of 67 then undecided; the last of them, Alaska, was called on November 17. Every model named that result as the thing that would move its number most, and the result landed at the far end of the range they drew:
- A Democratic Net Gain Of Four Or More Seats lowers the 2028 bar. Kimi said that case moves its number toward Democrats by eight to 12 points. The net gain by the AP's calls is nine, Alaska included.
- A Net Gain Of Zero Or One pushes it hard the other way. Opus said that case takes it to Republicans at 65. It did not happen.
Traders now make Democrats 88-cent favorites on this board. The 2026 Senate board that fed it closed at 99.9 cents for Democrats at 11:46 p.m. on November 3 and settled Yes at 12:46 a.m. the next morning; it stood at 63 on October 26 and at Republicans 53 on September 10. The 2026 House board settled Yes for Democrats 16 minutes later. Until the panel is re-run, the number on the right side of the table is an August number. On the left, the first real 2028 presidential polling matters most, because Nevada, Pennsylvania, Arizona and Georgia all track the top of the ballot. The new Senate is seated January 3, 2029, and the market settles February 1, 2029 on the party of the Senate's President pro tempore, which the majority elects, though Kalshi's rules allow it to settle early "based on a consensus of media calls projecting control of the U.S. Senate," which is how its 2026 sibling settled. Alaska's certification on November 25 is the last formality of the 2026 cycle, and with the seat already called and already in the price, the next thing likely to move the number is that first real 2028 polling.
Hottest Prediction Markets Right Now
- 2028 Democratic presidential nominee · $188M traded
- 2027 Pro Football Champion · $69M traded
- 2028 U.S. Presidential Election winner? · $61M traded
- 2028 Republican presidential nominee · $59M traded
- Pro Baseball Champion · $58M traded
- Bitcoin price at the end of 2026 · $32M traded
Every market above links to our full AI model verdict; browse them all on the OddsShopper prediction markets hub, and see how every settled call actually scored on the full graded scoreboard.
The Bottom Line
This board is no longer thin. The two 2028 Senate contracts have traded about 228,000 contracts combined since they opened in May 2026, about 41,000 of it on Thursday, November 5 alone and about 2,000 in the three days since November 16, against about 115 million on the 2026 Senate market that settled next door. An 88-cent print on a book with about 32,000 contracts of open interest is a market, not a handful of parked orders, and the two sweeps that tested it on election night and Wednesday morning, 5,261 contracts sold down to 66 and 3,261 sold down to 68, were both bought back to 85 or better within the hour. Since the November 4 update the side has not printed below 86, and the 3,474-contract buy at 88 on Thursday, November 5 went through at one price. On October 26 this page said two evenings accounted for more than a fifth of everything the board had ever traded; Wednesday, November 4 is still the busiest day, about 82,200 contracts, more than a third of everything the board has ever traded, and November 4 through this update accounts for about three quarters.
Thirty-seven points on each side is not a scandal. It is the price of an input. The panel priced this map in August with the midterm as a variable and landed on a coin flip; the midterm came in at the far end of the range the models drew, Democrats need 11 of the 34 seats still to be decided and hold 16 of them, and the market has done the arithmetic the panel said it would do. What the market has not done is price 2028's own election, two years out, with no presidential nominee on either side. That is the part of the question the 88 cents still has to answer.
Contracts on this board trade in cents and settle at either $1 or nothing, and a 33-cent move in the nine days around the midterm, with sweeps of 22 and 15 cents inside it, means the price you see may not be the price you get.
More on this: 2028 House Control Odds · 2028 Presidential Election Odds · 2026 Senate Races: Every Kalshi Board We Track · Senate Control 2026 Odds: The Four Seats That Decide It · Kalshi 2026 Senate Odds: Which Party Wins The Senate?




