Malachi Toney's Heisman contract is worth less tonight than it was the night he broke a 42-year-old Miami receiving record. He caught 12 passes for 234 yards and three touchdowns at Stanford on September 4, and the Kalshi market closed that night at 7 cents. He has since caught four more passes for 96 yards and a touchdown in a 77-7 win over Florida A&M, and 551,476 more contracts have traded in his name. As of 8:09 p.m. ET on Sunday, September 14, he is 5 cents bid, 6 cents ask. The board that watched him do all that has marked him down a penny.
| Player (school, position) | Price (bid / ask) | Traded, last 24h | Open interest |
|---|---|---|---|
| Darian Mensah (Miami, QB) | 15¢ / 16¢ | 18,988 | 1,107,022 |
| Jeremiah Smith (Ohio State, WR) | 10¢ / 11¢ | 9,118 | 968,922 |
| CJ Carr (Notre Dame, QB) | 8¢ / 11¢ | 879 | 673,521 |
| Arch Manning (Texas, QB) | 8¢ / 9¢ | 13,034 | 813,937 |
| Trinidad Chambliss (Ole Miss, QB) | 6¢ / 7¢ | 5,683 | 918,103 |
| Malachi Toney (Miami, WR) | 5¢ / 6¢ | 4,811 | 1,455,153 |
| Kamario Taylor (Mississippi State, QB) | 3¢ / 5¢ | 22,866 | 968,263 |
| Julian Sayin (Ohio State, QB) | 3¢ / 4¢ | 11,442 | 819,525 |
| Josh Hoover (Indiana, QB) | 3¢ / 4¢ | 3,367 | 560,656 |
| Jayden Maiava (USC, QB) | 3¢ / 4¢ | 2,014 | 694,657 |
| Gunner Stockton (Georgia, QB) | 3¢ / 4¢ | 7,690 | 593,199 |
Kalshi's public market data, captured September 14, 2026, at 8:09 p.m. ET. Every name not listed is bid at 2 cents or less. Across all 39 names the asks add to about $1.18, so the board prices to well over 100% at the ask, as every long-field award market does. The market settles when the Heisman is awarded in December.
The full 39-name board, every price and our models' number on each, is on the Heisman odds page.
Stay ahead of the markets.
Daily insights and expert picks on Kalshi, Polymarket, and what's moving markets.
Free forever. Unsubscribe anytime.
The Receiver Who Lost And Doubled
The row to read next to Toney's is Jeremiah Smith's. On Saturday, September 12, Ohio State lost at Texas 24-23. Smith caught eight passes for 164 yards and a touchdown in that loss. He was 5 cents bid, 6 ask on September 5, a penny behind Toney. He is 10 bid, 11 ask tonight, double Toney's price, on a team that just dropped a game.
Set the two side by side and the market's logic stops being about receiving. Toney has 16 catches for 330 yards and four touchdowns in two Miami wins by a combined 109 points, and his price is down two cents from its peak. Smith has a loss and a price that doubled. What changed for Smith was not production. It was that Ohio State played a real opponent and he was the best player on the field in a game the country watched. What has not changed for Toney is that Miami has beaten Stanford and Florida A&M, and nobody is handing a trophy for that.
Four Receivers In 90 Years
The discount is older than either of them. In roughly nine decades of voting, four wide receivers have won the Heisman: Johnny Rodgers in 1972, Tim Brown in 1987, Desmond Howard in 1991, and DeVonta Smith in 2020, with Travis Hunter adding a two-way win as a receiver and cornerback in 2024. Quarterbacks won 21 of the last 26. Of the names bid at 3 cents or higher on tonight's board, nine are quarterbacks and two are receivers, and neither receiver is asked above 11 cents.
DeVonta Smith's season shows where the bar sits. When ballots were due he had 98 catches for 1,511 yards on an undefeated Alabama team, and he still had to finish ahead of his own quarterback, Mac Jones, who came third. A receiver has to be so obviously the best player in the country that voters skip past the man throwing him the ball. Our five-model preseason panel put Toney at a 0.5% blend in July, when his contract was quoted a cent and a half bid, two and a half ask. Ten days after the biggest receiving night in Miami history, the market has him at 5, and the panel's number is the reason.
None of that is a knock on the player. Toney set Miami's single-season receptions record as a true freshman in 2025, went for 1,211 yards, and was a finalist for the Shaun Alexander Freshman of the Year Award on a team that reached the national championship game. The 234 yards passed Eddie Brown's 220, set in 1984. He is doing the things a great receiver does. The market is saying the award is not for that.
The Wall That Never Had To Fight
The September 4 spike was the largest one-day move this board has produced. In the hour ending at 10 p.m. ET, with Miami scoring on six of its first seven drives, 409,100 Toney contracts traded and the price climbed from 2 cents to 5. The hour ending at 11 did 138,887 and closed at 6. The hour ending at midnight did 80,995 and closed at 7. Then it stopped, and it never printed an 8.
The reason was sitting on the order book in plain sight. At 1:22 p.m. ET on September 5 there were 236,480 contracts offered at 7 cents, 300,005 at 8, and 510,000 at 9: 1,046,485 contracts stacked between 7 and 9, against 17,236 in total resting bids from 1 cent to 6. The sell side was roughly 60 times the buy side. Whoever put 510,000 contracts at 9 cents had decided Toney did not trade in double digits without going through them.
They never had to find out. The buying ran out first. Toney's lifetime volume has gone from 1,152,961 contracts to 1,704,437 and his open interest from 1,035,898 to 1,455,153, which means roughly 419,000 new positions opened in ten days and the price fell anyway. Tonight there are 327 contracts offered at the 6-cent ask and 1,204 bid at 5. The million-contract wall is gone because nothing is pushing against it.
The Mensah Problem
The name above Toney's is the other half of the answer. Darian Mensah, the Duke transfer throwing him the ball, opened the season at 10 cents and trades at 15 bid, 16 ask tonight, the top price on a 39-name board. In one game Miami produced the market's favorite and its most-traded contract, and they are two different people. On September 4 Toney's 234 yards were 58% of Mensah's 401. That share is the number voters read all season, and every receiver who has ever won this award had to make them stop reading it that way.
So the Hurricanes are competing for the same votes, and the board says the quarterback collects them at three times the receiver's price. If Miami keeps winning and the passing game keeps producing, that ratio is the thing to watch, because one of the two contracts is wrong. Mensah's own market has taken the opposite path over the same ten days: his sellers disappeared while Toney's never had to show up.
What A 5-Cent Contract Pays
Kalshi contracts pay $1.00 if the named player wins and nothing if he does not, settling after the December ceremony with a listed close of January 1, 2027. A buyer who takes 100 contracts at the 6-cent ask has $6.00 at risk and $100 coming back before fees if Toney wins, a little under 17 times the stake. The exit runs through the same book: the best bid is 5 cents, so a buyer who pays 6 and wants out immediately gives up a cent, about 17% of the money, before the fee touches anything. Re-run that at whatever price is on the screen when you look.
What Moves The Price From Here
Miami travels to Wake Forest on Friday, September 18, then hosts Central Michigan on September 26 before the schedule turns at Clemson on October 3. Nothing before Clemson gives a voter a reason to change a ballot, which is why Toney's price can sit where it is through two more wins. The signal to watch is not his yardage. It is whether the gap to Mensah closes: 5 cents against 15 is the market saying the quarterback is the story and the receiver is the evidence for it.
The other thing to watch is Jeremiah Smith, because his week proved what the board actually rewards. A receiver moves this market by being the best player in a game that matters, and a 77-7 win over Florida A&M is not that game. Toney gets his first one in three weeks. If you follow the exchange weekly, Lindy's Heisman Watch tracks the board, our free expert picks cover the college football game markets that will decide whether Miami stays in the race, and the prediction markets hub carries every live board we track, including the daily Kalshi read.
More on this: Darian Mensah Heisman Odds: The Sellers Have Given Up · Heisman Trophy Odds 2026: The One Price The Market Hasn't Moved · Jeremiah Smith Heisman Odds: Traders Doubt A Generational WR · AFC East Odds: Buffalo At 63¢, 8 Models Say New England · GTA 6 Release Date: Traders Are Betting November Holds
