Dan Driscoll worked his last full day as Secretary of the Army on Wednesday, September 2. The same day Senator Thom Tillis, a North Carolina Republican, posted that he had "never witnessed more inept management of the brave men and women who serve our country" and urged the president "to find a new leader at the Pentagon." That night Representative Don Bacon, another Republican, told CNN that Pete Hegseth "would not be on my team." By Thursday the White House had named an acting Army secretary and said the president "has complete trust in Secretary Hegseth."
That was the week of September 2. Since then the Hegseth out odds on Kalshi have run through two more deadlines and one election, and he is still Secretary of Defense. The out-before-October-1 contract settled No on October 1. The out-before-November-1 contract, the rung the first two editions of this page were built around, settled No on November 1 with its last trades at a cent or two. As of about 1 a.m. Eastern on Tuesday, November 10, 2026, the live ladder reads: out before November 16 at 8 bid, 9 ask, and out before December 1 at 21 bid, 22 ask. Out before January 1, 2027 is 36 bid, 37 ask. Out before February 1, 2027 is 62 bid, 63 ask. The December rung was 28 bid, 29 ask when this page was last stamped on September 4 and 21 to 23 on September 23. It is back where it was in late September, after a week that took it as high as 69 cents.
What changed is the size. The December rung carried about 24,900 open contracts on September 4 and about 55,800 on September 23. It carries about 534,500 now, with roughly 970,000 contracts traded over its life, most of them in the week since Election Day. A rung that did not exist a week ago, out before January 1, 2027, already holds about 319,000. The two questions this page exists to answer have moved down the calendar with the deadlines: what the market now says about him being gone by December 1 versus January 1, and why, after the loudest week of his tenure, the December price sits right where it sat before the election. There is also the loose end from the first edition, the price next door that did not fit the ladder. It fits again, and the gap between the two boards now says something specific; that is after the table.
Stay ahead of the markets.
Daily insights and expert picks on Kalshi, Polymarket, and what's moving markets.
Free forever. Unsubscribe anytime.
What Changed The Week Of September 2
The record, in order, because the market traded each item as it landed.
- Monday, August 31: the White House confirms Driscoll is leaving. Spokeswoman Anna Kelly said Driscoll had "been highly effective in advancing President Trump's agenda" and provided "outstanding leadership during historic military operations," the Associated Press reported via PBS News. A White House official said Driscoll had been asked to stay until after the midterms and told them it was time to go.
- Wednesday, September 2: his last full day, and a compliment for his boss. Driscoll said Wednesday was his last full day, called the job "the honor of a lifetime," and wrote that "we could not have made the progress we did without the support of Secretary Hegseth," per the AP's follow-up. He gave no reason for leaving. The friction with Hegseth, who in April pushed out the Army chief of staff and, per NBC, had fired people close to Driscoll and overruled his decisions, is covered below.
- Wednesday, September 2: Tillis tells Trump to replace him. In a post on X, Tillis wrote that a secretary "who maintained the same priorities and forward-thinking" would be "fighting to retain talented leaders like Dan and the many flag officers he has forced into retirement," that Hegseth "is intimidated by competence and retreats to ginning up culture wars," and that he urged the president "to find a new leader at the Pentagon who will retain and empower our military talent rather than diminish it," TIME reported. Asked about it, Trump said, "I think he's doing a fantastic job, but it's very early to talk about that."
- Wednesday night: Bacon agrees, and stops one step short. On CNN, Bacon said, "I hate to tell the president who he should hire and fire … but he would not be on my team," and that Hegseth "has not been a very good leader," per MS NOW. He did not call for a firing. Senator Mike Rounds, asked whether he still had confidence in Hegseth, answered that it is "a matter of whether the president" does. As of early September, The New Republic's tally of Republican criticism named no second member of Congress who had asked for his removal; Massie's impeachment push came later.
- Thursday, September 3: an acting secretary, and a vote of confidence. Trump named Adam Telle, the assistant Army secretary for civil works, acting Army secretary in a Truth Social post, Federal News Network reported. The White House told Fox News that "the President has complete trust in Secretary Hegseth, who is doing an incredible job leading the Pentagon."
Read that list the way a contract reads it. Every item is pressure on Hegseth. Not one is a departure, a departure date, or a president who sounds like he is looking for one. The rules on this ladder pay on a vacated office, not on a bad week, and the market priced the week accordingly.
The August Record The Criticism Sits On
The first edition of this page was built on a different document, and it still matters because it is the record the week's criticism sits on. In the August 14 edition of the Secretary of Defense Orders Book, the classified planning document that tells the Pentagon which ships, planes, and troops are available, the heads of the Army, Navy, and Air Force and the four-star commanders for Europe, the Pacific, and Latin America told Hegseth that stretching the Iran campaign any further was unsustainable, according to the Washington Post report carried by The Spokesman-Review on August 30. Four of them formally marked the orders "non-concur." Admiral Daryl Caudle, the Chief of Naval Operations, wrote that the Navy "cannot sustain its current level of support for the Iran conflict because there is no anticipated end date," with barely one-fourth of the destroyer fleet ready to deploy. The Jerusalem Post carried the same reporting.
The personnel record behind Driscoll's exit runs back to spring. Hegseth asked Army Chief of Staff General Randy George to retire, effective immediately, on April 2, per CBS News, and General Christopher LaNeve has served as acting chief since; CBS counted George among more than a dozen senior officers Hegseth has removed, a list that includes the former Chairman of the Joint Chiefs, General C.Q. Brown. General Chris Donahue, widely expected to be the next Army chief, stepped down as commander of Army forces in Europe and Africa in June after, in the phrasing of MS NOW's June 24 report, earning the ire of the secretary. NBC News reported on August 26 that Driscoll had told associates he wanted out by Labor Day, in part because Hegseth had fired people close to him and overruled his decisions. He beat that date by five days.
So the Army now has an acting secretary and an acting chief of staff, and the man who runs the department has a senator from his own party asking for his job. The price history spent the week pricing that setup.
How The Price History Traded That Week
The November rung was where that week showed up first, and where it showed up least. Monday evening, the day the White House confirmed Driscoll was leaving, the out-before-November-1 contract traded about 2,000 contracts in the 7 p.m. Eastern hour, one sweep at 7:46 p.m. clearing the book from 16 cents to 54, its largest fill 259 contracts at the top, before the hour closed at 18. From there it spent Tuesday and Wednesday between 11 and 25 cents, mostly 17 to 19, on roughly 23,200 contracts from midnight Tuesday through Friday's pull. About three-quarters of those contracts were bought by someone taking the yes side at the offer. A market where three-quarters of the volume is yes-buyers and the price goes from 16 to 18 is a market where the sellers are deep. Somebody was offering "he is gone before November" in size, taking the he-stays side, and they did not have to raise their price to keep doing it.
The heaviest hour on that rung since Monday night came Thursday evening, a day after Tillis and Bacon spoke and the afternoon Telle was named: 1,941 contracts across 31 trades in the 7 p.m. hour, all between 18 and 23 cents, the largest of the late fills a 266-contract print at 23 cents at 7:49 p.m., the hour's high. Open interest rose by about 1,850 contracts in that hour, so most of it was new positions, not old ones closing. An hour later the book was 19 bid, 21 ask. By 11 p.m. it was 18 bid, 19 ask. The shape is a market that was offered a reason to reprice and declined.
The tell of that weekabout three-quarters of the 23,000 contracts traded on the November rung since Tuesday were bought by yes-takers, and the price moved two cents. The sellers of "gone before November" were deep, and they did not have to raise their price.
December was the rung that actually moved that week, and it moved down. Monday's 31-to-36 quote, built on one thin weekend of trading after the Orders Book story, gave way Tuesday to a wide 21-to-29 book, recovered to the mid-30s Tuesday afternoon, and then spent Wednesday and Thursday grinding lower to 28 bid, 29 ask. The biggest single order of the week on the three-rung ladder landed here: at 9:40 p.m. Thursday, one buyer took about 2,500 contracts at 29 cents and another 690 at 30, in a 3,279-contract hour that was almost entirely yes-side takers. Open interest rose by about 3,270 in that hour, which means the order opened positions rather than closing them. And the price did not budge. Somebody wanted 3,000 contracts of "gone before December," got most of them at 29 and the rest at 30, and the market's next quote was 28 to 29.
October, the rung the first edition called cheap, doubled: 3 bid, 6 ask on Monday, 6 bid, 7 ask by that Friday, with the last trade at 9. Open interest went from about 2,200 on Monday to about 17,800. Cheap rungs move on small money, and this one still priced a September exit at roughly one chance in fifteen. The out-before-2027 contract, the deepest market on the board with more than a million contracts traded, took its own path: 29 cents Monday, a 23-cent low in the hour after midnight Tuesday on more than 10,000 contracts, a 37-cent high in the early hours Wednesday, and 31 bid, 32 ask Friday morning. Its open interest grew from about 354,000 to about 407,000 across the week. It was the calmest and best-funded verdict on this page, and it came in three cents higher than it started.
One more thing the quotes told you that week. November was 17 bid, 19 ask, a two-cent gap. December was 28 bid, 29 ask, one cent. The tighter spread sat on the rung that had just absorbed a 3,279-contract hour without moving, and that was not a coincidence: the size resting at the touch on this ladder lived in December. November's wider gap said fewer people were willing to quote the near deadline tightly, which is why a 1,941-contract hour could print 23 there and give the level back by 11 p.m.
Four Deadlines, One Schedule
Here is how the ladder works, because the whole read depends on it. Each rung is its own yes-or-no contract: will Hegseth have left the Secretary of Defense role before that date? Buy a yes at the 22-cent ask on the December rung and it pays $1.00 if he is gone by then, nothing if he is not. Since every earlier deadline is contained inside every later one (if he is out by November 16, he is also out by December 1 and January 1), the prices have to rise as you move down the calendar. A shorter deadline can never be more likely than a longer one, so its price has to be equal or lower.
That ordering is what turns a row of prices into a schedule. The price of the November 16 rung is the market's estimate for "gone by November 16." The difference between November 16 and December 1 is its estimate for "gone in the back half of November." The difference between December 1 and January 1 is "gone during December," and the difference between January 1 and February 1 is "gone during January." Read that way, the ladder stops being a row of contracts and becomes one probability spread across the winter.
The ladder also has a history, and it is now five entries long. Kalshi has listed Hegseth-out deadlines since April. The out-before-July-1 rung traded about 206,700 contracts and settled No. The out-before-August-1 rung traded about 226,900 and settled No. The out-before-September-1 rung closed the night of August 31 with about 475,100 traded and settled No. The out-before-October-1 rung, the one the first edition called cheap at 3 to 6 cents, traded about 80,000 and settled No. The out-before-November-1 rung, the one the first two editions of this page were built around, traded about 152,500, spent its last ten days at a cent or two, and settled No on November 1, two days before the midterm. Five monthly deadlines, five Nos. The April ouster of the Army chief predates the ladder; the series launched on April 7. On September 28 it added rungs out to January 1, 2029, on October 12 a February 1, 2027 rung, and on the evening of November 4, the day after the election, a November 16 rung and a January 1, 2027 rung.
Month By Month: What Dec 1 Versus Jan 1 Actually Prices
All prices are from Kalshi's public API, pulled at about 1 a.m. Eastern on Tuesday, November 10, 2026. Open interest is the number of contracts still held. The last column is my translation into what a $100 yes position pays back, stake included, if the contract settles Yes. The two settled rungs stay on the board, with their final numbers, because the ladder's record is part of its price.
| Out before | Bid / Ask | Last trade | Open interest | Contracts (lifetime) | Last 24 hours | $100 on yes pays (gross) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oct 1 | settled No | 1¢ | 53,473 at settlement | 80,049 | 0 | n/a |
| Nov 1 | settled No | 2¢ | 85,811 at settlement | 152,521 | 0 | n/a |
| Nov 16 | 8¢ / 9¢ | 9¢ | 97,971 | 150,484 | 58,638 | $1,111 |
| Dec 1 | 21¢ / 22¢ | 21¢ | 534,529 | 969,718 | 79,177 | $455 |
| Jan 1, 2027 | 36¢ / 37¢ | 37¢ | 319,090 | 468,749 | 111,150 | $270 |
| Feb 1, 2027 | 62¢ / 63¢ | 65¢ | 172,709 | 279,095 | 27,865 | $159 |
| Apr 1, 2027 | 72¢ / 82¢ | 85¢ | 132,727 | 195,397 | 8,748 | $122 |
| 2027 (departure board) | 34¢ / 35¢ | 35¢ | 848,251 | 2,205,996 | 163,907 | $286 |
The first seven rows are the KXHEGSETHOUT ladder; the two settled rungs show their final open interest and last trade. The eighth is Hegseth's contract on Kalshi's separate "who leaves the Trump administration in 2026" board, which asks the same question as the ladder's January 1 rung, whether he leaves the Secretary of Defense job before 2027; that board, name by name, is on our Trump cabinet departures page. Payouts are computed at the ask and rounded to the dollar, before Kalshi's fees. The ladder also lists rungs for July 2027 through January 2029, all quoted between 78 and 94 cents and left off the board because none holds more than about 22,500 open contracts.
Here is the same ladder against the September 4 quotes this page last carried, so you can see what two settled deadlines, a midterm and an impeachment resolution were worth.
| Deadline | Sep 4 bid / ask | Nov 10 bid / ask | Change at the midpoint | Open interest Sep 4 to Nov 10 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before Oct 1 | 6 / 7 | settled No, Oct 1 | to zero | about 17,800 to 53,500 at settlement |
| Before Nov 1 | 17 / 19 | settled No, Nov 1 | to zero | about 27,900 to 85,800 at settlement |
| Before Nov 16 | not listed | 8 / 9 | listed Nov 4 | 0 to about 98,000 |
| Before Dec 1 | 28 / 29 | 21 / 22 | down about 7 points | about 24,900 to 534,500 |
| Before Jan 1, 2027 (ladder) | not listed | 36 / 37 | listed Nov 4 | 0 to about 319,000 |
| Before 2027 (departure board) | 31 / 32 | 34 / 35 | up about 3 points | about 407,000 to 848,000 |
The September 4 figures are the ones this page carried in its previous edition. The November 16 and January 1 rungs were listed on the evening of November 4; their open interest has built in five days.
So, the answer to the question in the title of this section. Using midpoints, the market says Hegseth is gone by December 1 with about a 21 or 22 percent chance and gone by January 1 with about a 36 or 37 percent chance. Subtract down the column and the calendar reads: gone by November 16, roughly 8 or 9 points. Gone in the back half of November, roughly 13. Gone during December, roughly 15. Gone during January, roughly 26. Gone in February or March, roughly 14 or 15, with the wide-quoted April rung making that last number the softest on the page.
Compare that with the September 4 calendar of 6 or 7, 11 or 12, 10 or 11, and 3, and the whole shape has moved, not just one bucket. In September the market's heaviest month was October, which came and went without a departure. Now the heaviest month is January, after the new Congress is seated on January 3 with Democrats controlling both chambers, and it carries far more weight than December. The market is not pricing a quick exit around a House vote; the rung that covers the vote window, November 16, is in single digits. Impeachment is a charge, not a removal: conviction takes two-thirds of the Senate, which ABC's reporting calls unlikely, so the only fast path is still the president. It is pricing a slow one. The read I keep coming back to, and it is mine rather than the market's, is that the ladder has taken Representative Thomas Massie's own argument, that the proceeding gets messier once Democrats run Congress in January, with what he called a "robust trial" in the Senate, and priced the month after that date as the one when the pressure converts. That is a market view, not a forecast of what the president will do, and the president said on Monday he would stand by his defense secretary through an impeachment.
More live boards on the same question: Hegseth's rung on the full administration departure board sits at 34 bid, 35 ask with about 848,000 contracts open, the deepest single market on him anywhere on Kalshi. The Trump resignation market and the early-departure board price the man who would have to accept the resignation.
What Moved Since September 23
Here is what moved after September 23, when the December rung sat at 21 bid, 23 ask, the November rung at 6 to 7 cents and the October rung was already trading at a penny, in the order the market traded it. Daily prices are closes at midnight Eastern; the hours are from Kalshi's hourly candles.
Late September: December sags, and the ladder gets long. With no new Orders Book story and no new Republican voice, December drifted from 21 to 23 on September 23 to 15 bid, 18 ask by September 27, with one 2,800-contract hour on the afternoon of September 26 that printed as high as 56 cents and gave it all back by the next morning. On September 28 Kalshi listed six new rungs, from April 1, 2027 out to January 1, 2029. The out-before-October-1 rung settled No on October 1 at a last trade of 1 cent, on about 80,000 lifetime contracts.
October 12 to 16: a spike nobody could hold. Kalshi added a February 1, 2027 rung on October 12, and within three days it was trading in the 50s, the first sign the market saw a real window after the election rather than before it. The December rung, meanwhile, printed its strangest hour of the fall: in the last hour of October 14, 11 p.m. to midnight Eastern, about 6,800 contracts took it from 17 to a 62-cent high before it closed the hour at 36. By 6 a.m. it was 22 to 23, and by the close on October 15 it was 18 bid, 20 ask on about 12,400 contracts, the rung's busiest day to that point. That afternoon the White House said the Fort Hood shooter's execution would not be livestreamed after Hegseth's plan drew objections from both parties, the White House overruling him "again," in NBC's own phrasing, NBC News reported. I cannot tie the overnight spike to a story, and I am not going to pretend to. What I can say is that nothing that week moved the rung for longer than a few hours.
October 29: another general. Hegseth removed Army Lieutenant General Brett Sylvia as the Joint Staff's director of strategy, plans and policy, with no reason given and no replacement named, the second officer pushed out of that post in a year and one of nearly two dozen generals, admirals and other senior leaders to depart under him, the Associated Press reported via PBS News. The December rung closed October 28 at 26 bid, 27 ask and October 29, the day of the firing, at 29 bid, 31 ask, its highest close since the October 14 spike. October 30 gave it back, closing at 23 bid, 25 ask.
November 1: the second settlement. The out-before-November-1 rung expired at a last trade of 2 cents, having traded about 152,500 contracts in its life and spent its last ten days between a penny and three cents. It was the rung the first edition of this page said the Driscoll exit was "the exact condition" it was "built on." It settled No anyway.
November 3 and 4: the election, and the busiest day the ladder has ever had. Democrats won the House and flipped the Senate, Army Times reported, with the AP projecting at least 54 Senate seats, per Al Jazeera. On the morning of November 4 Vice President JD Vance wrote on X that "the reason we lost is the war," in the same Army Times report. The December rung had closed Monday, November 2 at 24 bid, 26 ask and Election Day itself at 40 bid, 41 ask, a 15-point jump on about 19,200 contracts as the returns came in. In the hour ending 1 p.m. Eastern on the 4th it ran from 56 to a 69-cent high on about 33,500 contracts, and the next hour gave the whole move back, closing at 35 on about 27,900. That evening NBC News reported that Trump had told some allies "in recent days" that he was considering replacing Hegseth, citing two people familiar with the discussions, while Trump himself told reporters that Hegseth was "doing a great job" and dismissed the idea, ABC News reported. The rung closed the day at 40 bid, 41 ask on about 287,000 contracts, more than it had traded in its entire life before that day. That evening Kalshi listed the November 16 and January 1, 2027 rungs; January's first hour of trading, the 8 p.m. hour Eastern, ran between 47 and 63 cents and closed at 62, and the rung ended the night at 55 bid, 58 ask.
November 5 and 6: the price comes down while the headlines get louder. Massie, who lost his primary this summer after Trump backed his opponent and whose first attempt died in September when the House recessed early, had said he would reintroduce his articles once the lame-duck session began. On the 5th Hegseth posted a video calling that effort "sham articles" dropped by "a disgruntled, defeated congressman," and Trump said he "has done a fantastic job," NBC News reported. The December rung fell from 41 to 27 bid, 28 ask on about 179,000 contracts, and the day-old January rung from 55 to 45 bid, 46 ask. On the 6th Trump announced that chief of staff Susie Wiles was leaving and that Stephen Miller would replace her on Monday; Hegseth's reaction on social media was "Patriots in control," per ABC7. December closed that day at 15 bid, 16 ask, its lowest close since October 12, and January at 31 bid, 32 ask. Two days of a president publicly standing behind his defense secretary, alongside the reported replacement talk and the chief-of-staff change, and the market took the December rung from 41 to 15.
November 8 and 9: the vote gets real, and the ladder barely blinks. On Sunday, House Democratic leader Hakeem Jeffries said on ABC's "This Week" that he was a "hard yes" on impeachment. On Monday, hours after the House returned, Massie read eight articles of impeachment on the floor over about an hour and twenty minutes; as a privileged resolution it has to be taken up within two legislative days, and with every Democrat it needs three Republicans to pass, or a simple majority to table, ABC News reported. Speaker Mike Johnson called impeachment "in the middle of hostilities abroad" a "terrible, terrible look," per the AP. Trump, at an impromptu briefing Monday afternoon, said he would "stand by" Hegseth even if he is impeached. Hegseth announced a Pentagon news conference for Tuesday, his first in more than 180 days, the AP reported. The market's response: in the hour ending 3 p.m. Monday the December rung ran from 22 to 32, touching 33, on about 12,300 contracts, and the November 16 rung ran from 14 to 26 on about 13,400. By the 6 p.m. hour December was back at 22 and November 16 at 8 bid, 9 ask, and the January rung, which had climbed back to 42 bid, 43 ask on Sunday, finished Monday at 36 bid, 37 ask.
Eight articles of impeachment read into the record moved the one-week rung to 26 cents for one hour and left it in single digits by dinner. The reading is the same one this page has carried since August: the rules pay on a vacated office, and the person who most controls that outcome is the president.
Open interest tells the other half. The December rung went from about 55,800 contracts on September 23 to about 112,700 at the close of Election Day to about 534,500 now; the January rung is at about 319,000 after five days. Those are positions still held, on both sides, through every one of the hours above. When I pulled the book, the best yes bid on December was 21 cents for about 1,800 contracts and the offers at 23 and 24 held about 8,700 between them, a snapshot, not a history. Somebody is still selling "he's gone by December" at 22 to 24 cents in size, taking the he-stays side, the same way somebody was selling the November version at 18 in September, and sellers of the five earlier deadlines were paid every time.
The Price Next Door Fits Again
Now the loose end. On Monday, August 31, "out before December 1" on this ladder was bid at 31 cents while Hegseth's before-2027 contract on the departure board was offered at 29, and I wrote that the ladder's own logic said that should not persist: every world where he is gone by December 1 is a world where he is gone by January 1, so the longer contract has to be worth at least as much. I said the deep market had the longer track record, that the 31-cent bid was the least settled number on the page, and that if December drifted back under 29 or the before-2027 contract firmed above it, the oddity would have resolved in the deeper market's favor.
Both happened by September 4, and the shape has held through everything since. December is 21 bid, 22 ask. The departure board's before-2027 contract is 34 bid, 35 ask. And the ladder's own January 1, 2027 rung, which asks the identical question in its rules, is 36 bid, 37 ask. The 13 to 15 points between December and the two year-end contracts is the market's price on a December exit, which is the shape a ladder is supposed to have. The two cents between the two year-end contracts is two deep books, about 848,000 and 319,000 contracts open, disagreeing by about the size of a single Kalshi fee at that price, roughly 1.6 cents a contract, and by less than the roughly 3 cents it would cost to trade both sides, which is to say not disagreeing at all. In September the correction came out of the thin rung, the way these usually resolve. This time there is no thin rung in the argument. Keep that in mind the next time a three-day-old rung on any board prints a number the deep market next to it disagrees with.
What Has To Happen For November To Pay
The contract language is stricter than the headlines. Kalshi's rules say Hegseth "must have an actual departure date and vacate the role within the time period." A temporary leave, a suspension, or a recusal does not count. Neither does an announced resignation with an effective date on the far side of the deadline. If he announces on November 20 that he will step down effective January 15, the out-before-December-1 contract settles No, the out-before-January-1 contract settles No, and the first rung on the ladder to pay is February 1.
So for the November 16 rung to pay, one of a small number of things has to happen inside a week: a resignation that takes effect within days, the way cabinet exits sometimes do when the announcement and the departure land together; a removal by the president; or a departure tied to a specific event, with a successor already named. On August 31 I wrote that Driscoll's exit was "the exact condition the November rung is built on." It arrived September 2, the rung went from 16 to 18, and two months later it settled at zero. That is still the most useful single fact on this page. The condition the market was supposedly waiting for showed up, the loudest week of Republican criticism showed up, eight articles of impeachment showed up, and the deadlines kept settling No. The market is waiting for the president, and on Monday he answered for himself: he would "stand by" Hegseth even if the House impeaches him.
The December rung needs the same thing to happen with three weeks of runway, and the midterm it was waiting for has come and gone. Every path to a quick post-election reshuffle lives inside that rung. On September 4 the market charged 28 points for the whole path through December 1; it now charges 21 or 22 for the three weeks that are left. The weight the market used to put on a fast exit has moved out to the January rung, and the reason is on the calendar: a Democratic House and Senate are seated on January 3.
Why October Doubled And Still Settled No
A 6-cent October rung after a week like the first one on this page looked like a market ignoring the news. It was a market that had run this experiment three times, and it was right a fourth and a fifth time: the October rung settled No on October 1 and the November rung settled No a month later. Three monthly deadlines, a summer of firings and warnings, a service secretary's exit, and three contracts that had settled No. A trader who had watched all three had learned that pressure on this secretary does not convert to a vacated office on any short clock. The November 16 rung at 8 to 9 cents, with an impeachment vote possibly inside its window, is the same lesson priced again.
Add the mechanics from the previous section and October was hard to make pay even if a decision had already been made. A departure announced in mid-September with a two- or three-week transition, a normal shape for a cabinet exit, would have landed on the far side of October 1. So the rung doubling from 3 to 6 was not a signal of much. Open interest grew by about 15,000 contracts through that doubling, from a Monday base of about 2,200, and a rung that cheap reprices on far less. The market did not doubt the pressure; three settled Nos had taught it that the calendar between an announcement and an empty office usually runs past the nearest deadline. It ran past two more.
Go back to Caudle's destroyer number, one-fourth of the fleet ready to deploy, and add the Army's civilian and uniformed leadership both sitting in acting hands. That is the kind of record that ends careers over quarters, not weeks. A market that priced it into the year-end contracts and left the near rung in single digits read it the same way in September, and it reads it the same way now.
What To Watch Next
Four things can move this ladder before December 1, and the first of them is on the House floor this week.
The first is the House vote. Massie's resolution is privileged, so the House has to deal with it within two legislative days of Monday; with every Democrat it passes with three Republicans, or leadership tables it with a simple majority. The market has already shown you how it treats the vote: the November 16 rung touched 26 cents in the 2-to-3 p.m. hour Monday, the afternoon the articles were read and Trump said he would stand by Hegseth, and was back under 10 by 6 p.m. A vote that passes and a president who repeats "stand by" is the scenario the ladder is priced for. A vote that passes and a president who goes quiet is the one it is not. Tillis was the only senator from his own party to ask for his job in September, and as of this stamp I found no second one; the pressure moved to the House instead. Hegseth's Tuesday news conference, his first in six months, is the first test of whether he sounds like a man planning to stay.
The second is the Army secretary nomination. Adam Telle has been acting since September 3, and I could find no nomination for the permanent job as of this stamp. Whoever Trump nominates, and how fast, will tell the market whether the administration is stabilizing the building around Hegseth or preparing to reorganize it. A quick nomination of a Hegseth ally reads as the former.
The third is the next Orders Book. The document is produced twice a month, per the Post's August reporting, and I cannot tell you what the editions since then said; none has leaked in a form I can cite. A second round of non-concurs from the service chiefs would tell the market the objection is standing rather than a one-off. A quiet edition would say the August warnings were absorbed, and that is the outcome the 22-cent December price is closer to.
The fourth is the gap between December 1 and January 1. It is about 15 points now, against about 13 for the back half of November and about 26 for January itself. If December widens toward January, traders have started pricing an exit before the new Senate is seated, which is what a president who wanted a confirmable replacement would need. If January keeps growing while December sits, the market is telling you that if he goes, it will be after the gavel changes hands, not before.
Kalshi's departure board settled Yes on three names in the past week, Ric Grenell, Susie Wiles and Stephen Miller, the last of them because a deputy chief of staff who becomes chief of staff has left the deputy job the market was written on, and the mechanics of how Kalshi decides someone has "left" are worth ten minutes if you are new to these boards; our election prediction markets explainer covers how a yes-or-no contract turns into a probability. Everything else on the prediction markets hub runs the same way: real prices, real settlement rules, and the reading between them. And if you are here from the sports side, our free expert picks board runs the same discipline on tonight's games, and the toolkit behind it starts with a free week trial.
Prices move daily; the numbers above are a snapshot from the early hours of November 10, 2026, not a standing quote. Re-run the arithmetic at whatever price you are actually offered.
Disclosure: Stokastic Inc. trades prediction markets and may hold positions in markets discussed here. We have no affiliate or commercial relationship with Kalshi. 18+, available where Kalshi operates. Nothing in this article is a pick, a recommendation, or trading advice.
More on this: Raiders Vs Dolphins Props: Bowers Is Out, Kalshi Prices Him Like He Plays · Cash Out Vs Hedging On Kalshi: One Ticket, Two Exits (2026) · Why Pete Ricketts (R) Will Win the Nebraska Senate Race · How Kalshi Cash Out Works (Why You Get Less) · Cash Out Or Let It Ride? A Decision Framework For Kalshi Positions




