Jacksonville won 13 games last season, took the AFC South by a game, and earned the AFC's number three seed. Seven months later, the exchange where people put real money on this question has the Jaguars a distant second in their own division, well behind a Houston team they finished ahead of.
That is either the market seeing something the standings missed, or the market being talked out of a 13-win season. We handed eight AI models the whole division without letting any of them see a price, and they came back with a different order at the top.
The full board, every model's number, and the scheduling quirk that costs one of these teams two home games are below.
Free: The Weekly PM Market Brief — the 8-model panel's graded record, the week's biggest market-vs-model gaps, and what's spiking next. One email, Sundays.
New to event contracts? How to trade NFL on Kalshi explains how these contracts price and settle before you read a board like this one.
These are market prices and model estimates, not predictions of fact and not financial advice. Kalshi is a CFTC-regulated event-contract exchange (18+; availability varies by state).
The Champion Nobody Wants To Back
Start with what actually happened in 2025, because the market and the models are reading the same season in opposite directions.
Jacksonville went 13-4 with a point differential of plus 138, the best in the division. Both halves of the team worked: sixth in the league in points scored, eighth in points allowed. Houston went 12-5 at plus 109, and that number leaned almost entirely on one side of the ball. The Texans allowed 295 points, second-fewest in football. They scored 404, which ranked 13th.
Then January inverted it. Jacksonville, the three seed, lost its only playoff game at home, 27-24 to Buffalo. Houston, the five seed, went to Pittsburgh and won 30-6, then lost 28-16 at New England in the divisional round.
The division's runner-up won a playoff game by 24 points on the road. Its champion lost one at home. That is the last football either team played, and it is where the market's case against Jacksonville begins.
The offseasons pulled the same way. Houston spent it on the thing that broke: the offensive line. The Texans re-signed right guard Ed Ingram, drafted center-guard Keylan Rutledge in the first round, and signed guard Wyatt Teller and right tackle Braden Smith in free agency, per NFL.com's division camp preview. That was a direct answer to C.J. Stroud's 2025, which produced 3,041 passing yards and 19 touchdowns, both career lows, and a PFF grade that fell to 32nd among qualified quarterbacks after he ranked 13th as a rookie.
Jacksonville kept its head coach and its quarterback and lost its lead back, with Travis Etienne gone. Liam Coen enters year two off a 13-win debut.
So the market has a coherent story. It just requires two Houston things to break right at once, and the panel kept noticing that the second one has been breaking wrong all August.
What 24 Seasons Of This Division Say
The AFC South has run in eras since the 2002 realignment created it, and the titles are lopsided: Indianapolis nine times, Houston eight, Tennessee four, Jacksonville three. It has also run in eras. Indianapolis took seven of eight titles between 2003 and 2010. Houston has won eight of the 15 since.
Three numbers out of that history matter for this board.
- The repeat rate is 48 percent. The defending AFC South champion has won it again 11 times in 23 chances. That is not a curse and not a coronation, and it is meaningfully higher than the 25 percent a four-team division would produce by chance.
- A title here usually costs 11 wins. The average AFC South champion has won 11.2 games, and none has ever won fewer than nine. This is not a division that gets stolen at 8-9.
- Being good is not the same as winning it. Houston took this division in 2016 with a point differential of minus 49, in 2019 at minus 7, and in 2024 at exactly zero. Three of the last ten champions here were outscored on the season or broke even. A division title is a 17-game tiebreaker, not a referendum on quality.
One more piece of context for how strong last season was. Across all 192 division-seasons since 2002, only 13 have featured two teams at a .700 win percentage or better. The 2025 AFC South was one of them, with Jacksonville at 13-4 and Houston at 12-5. That is a 7 percent occurrence, and both of those teams are still here.
What This Contract Actually Settles
Kalshi's AFC South event (KXNFLAFCSOUTH-27) lists the division's four teams as four separate yes-or-no contracts. Each settlement rule is one sentence with the team name swapped. Houston's reads: "If Houston wins the Pro Football AFC South Division, then the market resolves to Yes." Kalshi names the league itself as the settlement source.
Three features of that rule change how you read the board.
- It settles on the division title, not on record. If two teams finish level, the NFL's published tiebreaker sequence decides it, starting with head-to-head, then division record, then common games, then conference record. Exactly one team is named champion every season, so there is no split payout. These four contracts describe one winner between them.
- It is not a playoff market. Houston went 12-5 last season, won a road playoff game, and the equivalent contract still settled no. A team can have a very good year on this board and pay nothing.
- It closes early. Contracts expire once a champion is declared, with an expected expiration of January 11, 2027, the day after Week 18.
On liquidity, the four contracts have traded about 173,800 contracts between them, with roughly 141,200 still open. Each of the four is quoted a penny wide, tight enough that the midpoints below are real prices rather than a screen with nobody behind it. The oddity is where the volume sits: Tennessee, the cheapest contract on the board, carries the most lifetime volume of the four at about 58,000.
Prices below are the midpoint of the live bid and ask as of August 24, 2026, and the panel's numbers were generated the same day. Prices on this page refresh while the story moves.
Where This Division Was Actually Decided Last Year
The twelve intra-division games did not separate the top two at all. Jacksonville and Houston both finished 5-1 inside the AFC South, which means they split their head-to-head and each went 4-0 against Indianapolis and Tennessee. Indianapolis went 2-4, beating only the Titans, and Tennessee went 0-6. The 2025 title was settled by one game outside the division, not by anything that happened between these four teams.
The 2026 pairings are set the same way, home and away, and two dates carry most of the weight. Houston and Jacksonville meet at Wembley Stadium in London on October 18 and again in Houston on December 20. The season then closes on January 10, 2027 with Jacksonville at Indianapolis and Tennessee at Houston, which is exactly the kind of Week 18 that decides a tiebreaker.
The Board
The AI blend is the median of eight independent models after a revision round in which each one read the others' reasoning without knowing which model wrote what.
| Team | 2025 record and point differential | Kalshi | AI blend |
|---|---|---|---|
| Houston Texans | 12-5, +109 | 45.5¢ | 34.5% |
| Jacksonville Jaguars | 13-4, +138 | 28.5¢ | 35.0% |
| Indianapolis Colts | 8-9, +54 | 19.5¢ | 23.5% |
| Tennessee Titans | 3-14, -194 | 9.5¢ | 6.0% |
The market and the panel agree on the bottom half of this board and disagree about who is favored at the top. Houston is the panel's biggest fade of the four, 11 points below its price.
How To Read This Board
A price in cents is roughly the market's implied chance. Houston at 45.5¢ means traders collectively give the Texans about a 45.5 percent chance, close to +120 at a sportsbook, and a contract that resolves yes pays $1. Jacksonville at 28.5¢ is about +251, Indianapolis at 19.5¢ about +413, Tennessee at 9.5¢ about +953.
Because the NFL always names one champion, these four contracts cover every outcome. They are still four separately quoted markets, so the midpoints need not total exactly 100 cents. Here they sum to 103, the small premium you would expect to pay buying every side of a tight board.
The blend column is a median of eight separate estimates rather than one distribution, so it also need not total 100. It sums to 99.
Every Seat's Number
| Model | Houston | Jacksonville | Indianapolis | Tennessee |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Claude Fable | 34.0% | 37.0% | 22.0% | 7.0% |
| Claude Opus | 33.0% | 36.0% | 25.0% | 6.0% |
| Claude Sonnet | 36.0% | 33.0% | 24.0% | 7.0% |
| GPT | 34.0% | 37.0% | 23.0% | 6.0% |
| Gemini | 36.0% | 34.0% | 24.0% | 6.0% |
| GLM | 35.0% | 33.0% | 23.0% | 9.0% |
| Kimi | 36.0% | 34.0% | 24.0% | 6.0% |
| DeepSeek | 33.0% | 38.0% | 23.0% | 6.0% |
| Median | 34.5% | 35.0% | 23.5% | 6.0% |
Every seat on this panel is graded against real market settlements — records to date: Claude Fable 84% on 707 graded calls · Claude Opus 84% on 777 graded calls · Claude Sonnet 82% on 755 graded calls · GPT 84% on 6,039 graded calls · Gemini 86% on 4,746 graded calls · GLM 81% on 2,504 graded calls · Kimi 83% on 2,494 graded calls · DeepSeek 80% on 2,542 graded calls. Recomputed daily; the full scoreboard is public.
Every number here gets graded in public once the market settles; the full graded scoreboard carries each seat's running record.
Read down the Houston and Jacksonville columns and the honest finding is not that the panel loves the Jaguars. Four seats put Houston first, four put Jacksonville first, and all eight landed both teams between 33 and 38 percent. The panel's argument with the market is not about which team is better. It is that the market has separated these two by 17 cents and the panel cannot separate them at all.
More live boards from the same panel: AFC North odds with Baltimore at 45.5¢ and Cincinnati at 33.5¢ · AFC West odds where Kansas City, the Chargers and Denver sit inside two cents of each other · AFC Championship 2027 odds with Buffalo at 15.5¢. Prices fetched August 24, 2026.
Hottest Prediction Markets Right Now
- 2028 Democratic presidential nominee · $191M traded
- 2027 Pro Football Champion · $71M traded
- 2028 U.S. Presidential Election winner? · $62M traded
- 2028 Republican presidential nominee · $60M traded
- Pro Baseball Champion · $59M traded
- Bitcoin price at the end of 2026 · $33M traded
Every market above links to our full AI model verdict; browse them all on the OddsShopper prediction markets hub, and see how every settled call actually scored on the full graded scoreboard.
Houston Texans: An Elite Defense And A Thin Receiver Room
Every seat built Houston's case on the same fact. The Texans allowed 17.4 points a game, second in the NFL, in DeMeco Ryans's fourth season, and several seats argued that a point differential built on defense repeats more reliably than one built on a hot offense. The bear case arrived in the last two weeks, and it is why no seat pushed Houston into the 40s. Houston placed second-year receiver Jayden Higgins on injured reserve on August 21 with a knee injury, with a torn ACL reported by ESPN's Adam Schefter. Tank Dell is, in Ryans's words, "on his own plan," and Ryans said on August 17 he was unsure whether Dell would play at all in the preseason. Houston has since added Zay Jones and Sterling Shepard, both now on the active roster.
"What keeps Houston at 33 rather than lower is the OL rebuild (Rutledge, Teller, Smith, Ingram) aimed straight at Stroud's collapse to a 32nd PFF grade. What keeps it from being higher is the receiver ledger: Higgins on IR with a torn ACL, Dell 'on his own plan,' and Zay Jones and Sterling Shepard signed off tryouts — a rebuilt line can't throw to itself."
— Claude Opus
One structural note: Houston's first three division games are all away from home, at Indianapolis in Week 3, at Tennessee in Week 5 and against Jacksonville in London in Week 6. The Texans do not host a division opponent until November 19.
Jacksonville Jaguars: Two Of Their Home Games Are In London
Here is the fact that shows up in no record or differential. Jacksonville is the designated home team for eight games in 2026, and two of them are in England.
The Jaguars host Philadelphia at Tottenham Hotspur Stadium in Week 5 and Houston at Wembley in Week 6, back to back. That leaves six actual dates at EverBank Stadium, the fewest true home games in the division, and it puts the biggest game on their schedule on neutral turf. Their bye follows in Week 7, which softens the trip without giving the home dates back.
Their slate is the hardest in the division too: measured by opponents' 2025 win percentage, Jacksonville draws a .490 schedule against Houston's .474 and Indianapolis's .465. Against all of that, they have the sturdiest 2025 profile on the board and continuity everywhere Houston has churn. Trevor Lawrence is healthy, Coen is in year two, and the line added Daniel Faalele from the Giants on August 19 for a 2027 sixth-round pick.
"Jacksonville's balanced +138 with both units top-eight is sturdier than Houston's defense-only +109 behind a 32nd-graded quarterback and a receiver room losing bodies in August."
— Claude Fable
One live friction: reporting on Jacksonville's plan to use Travis Hunter as a primary cornerback and part-time receiver drew public pushback from Hunter. Seven of the eight seats named that dispute in their revision round, every one of them as something that would move their Jacksonville number in one direction or the other.
The history cuts against them, and it is worth stating precisely. Jacksonville has won this division three times, in 2017, 2022 and 2025, and has never followed one with another. Set that against the 48 percent repeat rate above and the Jaguars are the one club here that has never converted it.
Indianapolis Colts And Tennessee Titans: The 7-2 Team And The Rebuild
This is where the panel and a record-based reading part company hardest, and all eight seats got there independently. The Colts' 8-9 was two seasons wearing one record. Indianapolis was 7-2 at the November 2025 trade deadline and lost its last seven games, per ESPN, after quarterback Daniel Jones tore his Achilles in Week 14. The point differential survived it at plus 54, better than the record and better than any other 8-9 team in the league.
At that same deadline the Colts sent their 2026 and 2027 first-round picks plus receiver Adonai Mitchell to the Jets for cornerback Sauce Gardner, a two-time first-team All-Pro. The seven-game collapse meant the 2026 pick conveyed at number 16 overall rather than the late first they had expected. They added Keenan Allen in August, who made his practice debut on the 20th.
Jones is the expected Week 1 starter and did not play in the preseason. That is the discount, and it is the single most-cited swing factor on this board: four of the eight seats put a number on it, each landing Indianapolis in the mid-teens or lower if Jones is limited. The rest of the case is arithmetic. The Colts draw the division's easiest slate at .465 and scored 27.4 points a game last season, eighth in the league, while allowing 24.2, which ranked 21st.
Dark Horses The Panel Won't Dismiss
A four-team board only has one contract under a dime, and Tennessee is it at 9.5¢. The panel sits below that at 6 percent, and no seat quite matched the market. GLM came closest at 9, and its reasoning is worth hearing: "Tennessee gets 9 for legitimate infrastructure (Saleh, Daboll, Ward year 2) but -194 and 0-6 in division is too deep a hole for one season." DeepSeek held 6 and called it "a worst-to-first tail event."
The infrastructure is real. Tennessee hired Robert Saleh as head coach and, on January 27, 2026, Brian Daboll as offensive coordinator, with Gus Bradley running the defense. Daboll was Buffalo's offensive coordinator for Josh Allen's first four seasons and has eight years as an NFL coordinator behind him. Cam Ward, the 2025 number one overall pick, is in year two.
What no seat could get past is the size of the gap. Tennessee scored 16.7 points a game, 30th, allowed 28.1, 28th, and went 0-6 inside the division. Against an average champion's 11.2 wins, the Titans won three.
Where The Panel Changed Its Mind
After round one, each model read the other seven arguments anonymously and could revise. What came back is the most telling number on this page: six of the eight seats swapped their top team between rounds. Three moved from Houston to Jacksonville, three moved from Jacksonville to Houston, and only Claude Fable and Claude Sonnet finished on the team they started with. A panel that cannot hold an order across one reading of its own arguments is telling you something about the order.
DeepSeek made the single largest revision, moving Houston from 38 to 33 and Jacksonville from 25 to 38. Its first-round case was that a defense-driven point differential repeats better than an offense-driven one. Its second-round case kept the principle and changed the conclusion:
"The real differentiator is Houston's receiving corps: Jayden Higgins is out with a torn ACL, Tank Dell is on an undefined plan, and Jaylin Noel is questionable, forcing the Texans to sign Zay Jones and Sterling Shepard off August tryouts. Even with a rebuilt offensive line, C.J. Stroud's 32nd-ranked PFF season may not reverse without weapons, and a defense-driven +109 net tends to regress."
— DeepSeek
Claude Opus moved less and caught more. One seat had argued in round one that Houston opened with three of its first four division games at home. Opus checked it against the schedule and said so:
"Forecaster A's claim that Houston opens with three of four division games at home is contradicted by the card — Houston's first three division games (Weeks 3, 5, 6) are all road/London; that removed a reason to lift Houston."
— Claude Opus
GLM is the only seat whose Houston number did not move at all, sitting at 35 in both rounds. Its switch to Houston came entirely from the other side of the ledger, marking Jacksonville down from 40 to 33: "Houston's easier schedule, elite repeatable defense, OL rebuild targeting its weakness, and playoff run edge Jacksonville's never-repeated profile and hardest slate."
What Would Change The Panel's Mind
Four triggers, each one checkable, drawn from what the seats named themselves:
- Tank Dell cleared for full Week 1 participation, or another Houston skill-position loss. Cleared pushes Houston up three to four points and makes it the panel's favorite too. Another loss pushes it below Jacksonville on nearly every seat's board.
- Daniel Jones's status through the September practice reports. Full mobility moves Indianapolis toward 28 percent. A setback, or Anthony Richardson Sr. named the Week 1 starter against Baltimore, drops the Colts under 15 and sends those points to the top two.
- Stroud's efficiency through Weeks 1 to 4 behind the new line. Kimi put a number on it: top-12 efficiency pushes Houston toward 45, roughly where the market already has it.
- Resolution of the Travis Hunter role split. Settled cleanly, three seats move Jacksonville above Houston. Dragging into the season, the same three move it down.
Settlement Timeline
| Date | What happens |
|---|---|
| September 13, 2026 | Week 1. Buffalo at Houston, Cleveland at Jacksonville, Baltimore at Indianapolis, the Jets at Tennessee |
| September 27, 2026 | Week 3. Houston at Indianapolis, the season's first division game |
| October 18, 2026 | Week 6. Houston vs Jacksonville at Wembley Stadium, London |
| December 20, 2026 | Week 15. Jacksonville at Houston, the rematch |
| January 10, 2027 | Week 18. Jacksonville at Indianapolis and Tennessee at Houston close the regular season |
| January 11, 2027 | Expected expiration. Contracts can close earlier once a champion is declared |
This board gets re-scored when the story moves. Prices and panel numbers on this page are as of August 24, 2026.
The panel's calls are on the record. Our 8-model AI panel puts a graded, public verdict on the conference this division feeds into. See the live model verdict on the AFC Championship, or the full NFL board index for every market we track this season.
The Bottom Line
The market has decided that Houston's elite defense plus a fixed offensive line beats Jacksonville's balanced 13-win season, and it has priced that conviction at 17 cents. The panel found the reasoning sound and the 17 cents indefensible. Shown the same data and no prices, its median put Jacksonville a half point ahead of Houston, which is another way of saying a 45.5¢ favorite and a 28.5¢ second look like the same team.
If the models are right about that, the gap is the story. If the market is right, the burden sits on Stroud, and he will be throwing to a receiver room that has lost one receiver to injured reserve and has another on an open-ended plan, both since the start of August.
Either way, this one starts resolving on October 18, at Wembley.
