Final: Ravens 30, Falcons 23, in overtime. The backup changed everything, just not the way the Sims drew it. Tyler Huntley tied the game with 40 seconds left and won it on a one-yard sneak, and the short, run-first night this page was built on turned into 53 points and an extra period. Of the four bets, NO on Mark Andrews scoring and YES on Huntley 125+ passing yards cashed; NO on Michael Penix Jr. 200+ and the small YES on Justice Hill lost. Every contract below has settled. The prices are the Sunday board the picks were made against, each table carries a Result column, and the results were re-pulled from Kalshi and ESPN on Sunday, Oct. 18, 2026, at 1:40 a.m. ET.
Lamar Jackson was out, Tyler Huntley started for Baltimore, and the Sims rebuilt the Sunday night game at 11:29 a.m. CT with that lineup. The price on the Falcons went up with the news. The bets that paid were not about the Falcons winning. They were about what a Huntley game looks like, and what it does to the quarterback on the other sideline.
Stokastic's Sims, 10,000 runs of the 8:20 p.m. ET kickoff at Mercedes-Benz Stadium, had Atlanta winning 59.1% of the time against a 63.6¢ price, so the favorite was 4¢ too dear and the Ravens at 40.7¢ were fair. Neither side of the game was the bet. The props were.
Ask the Sims is the question box on the free Kalshi Combo Simulator: type a prop in plain English and it counts how often it hits across the 10,000 Sims, with the Kalshi price beside it. Each bet below starts with the question I typed into it Sunday afternoon and the card it sent back, then a verdict on the price and, in the table, the result.
Inactives (ESPN, 6:55 p.m. ET): Lamar Jackson was out and Tyler Huntley started for Baltimore, with center Cam Jurgens and linebacker Trey Hendrickson also out; Zay Flowers and Marlon Humphrey were questionable. Atlanta was without Za'Darius Smith; Jake Matthews, Divine Deablo and Samson Ebukam were questionable. No player on a card below was out, and all five questionable names played. Prices below were re-stamped from the Kalshi board at 6:55 p.m. ET.
Building it on DraftKings or FanDuel instead?The free DraftKings Parlay Simulator and FanDuel Parlay Simulator on Stokastic.com price these same props from the same 10,000 Sims, and the Polymarket Combo Simulator prices them in Polymarket's cents.
Penix Stays Under 200
NO on Michael Penix Jr. 200+ passing yards · 40.7¢ (+146) on Kalshi · 48.3% in the Sims · Result: lost, 240 yards
What I asked: "How often does Michael Penix Jr. throw for 200+ yards?"
The answer card from Ask the Sims in the Kalshi Combo Simulator, Sunday afternoon. Tap it to ask your own question about this game.
The card sent you to the other side. Two hundred yards cost 63.6¢ for something the Sims saw in 51.7% of games, which was 12¢ against anyone buying the over. The under at 40.7¢ against 48.3% was the widest gap in this game. With Huntley at quarterback, Baltimore runs Derrick Henry and shortens the game, and a short game means fewer Atlanta drives and fewer Penix throws, in a game the Sims had the Falcons leading more often than not.
| Contract | Price | Why | Result | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| BUY | NO on Michael Penix Jr. 200+ passing yards | 40.7¢ (+146) | Under 200 in 48.3% of the Sims; 8¢ of edge | Lost (240 yards) |
| SKIP | YES on Michael Penix Jr. 200+ passing yards | 63.6¢ (-175) | 51.7% in the Sims; 12¢ against you | Hit (240 yards) |
| SKIP | YES on Michael Penix Jr. 175+ passing yards | 76.3¢ (-322) | 67.4% in the Sims; 9¢ against you, the same overpay one rung down | Hit (240 yards) |
Stay ahead of the markets.
Daily insights and expert picks on Kalshi, Polymarket, and what's moving markets.
Free forever. Unsubscribe anytime.
Andrews Doesn't Score
NO on Mark Andrews scores a TD · 77.3¢ (-341) on Kalshi · 83.2% in the Sims · Result: cashed, no touchdown
What I asked: "How often does Mark Andrews score a touchdown?"
The answer card from Ask the Sims, Sunday afternoon. Tap it to ask your own question about this game.
This was a fade of the price, not the player. Andrews was priced like Lamar Jackson's red-zone target, 27.3¢ on the card, and the Sims gave him 16.9% with Huntley throwing. A Huntley offense scores on the ground: Henry scored in 53.8% of the runs, and the tight end's share of the end zone shrinks when the quarterback's first read on the goal line is a handoff.
| Contract | Price | Why | Result | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| BUY | NO on Mark Andrews scores a TD | 77.3¢ (-341) | 83.2% in the Sims; 6¢ of edge | Cashed (4 catches, no touchdown) |
| SKIP | YES on Mark Andrews scores a TD | 26.3¢ (+280) | 16.9% in the Sims; 9¢ against you | Missed (no touchdown) |
| SKIP | YES on Derrick Henry scores a TD | 56.7¢ (-131) | 53.8% in the Sims; the likeliest Raven, priced 3¢ past it | Hit (18-yard touchdown catch) |
Hill For A Small Stake
Justice Hill scores a TD · 11.7¢ (+755) on Kalshi · 17.8% in the Sims · Result: lost, no touchdown
What I asked: "How often does Justice Hill score a touchdown?"
The answer card from Ask the Sims, Sunday afternoon. Tap it to ask your own question about this game.
Hill is Baltimore's second back and its passing-down back, and a Huntley game is a short-pass game. The Sims gave him 17.8% to score, against a price that treated him as an afterthought. It paid more than seven to one and hit a little better than one game in six in those runs.
| Contract | Price | Why | Result | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Buy Small | YES on Justice Hill scores a TD | 11.7¢ (+755) | 17.8% in the Sims; 6¢ of edge on the second back | Lost (73 rushing yards, no touchdown) |
| SKIP | YES on Bijan Robinson scores a TD | 66.6¢ (-199) | 62.1% in the Sims; the likeliest scorer in the game, priced 4¢ past it | Missed (no touchdown) |
| SKIP | YES on Drake London scores a TD | 43.7¢ (+129) | 44.9% in the Sims; a cent of edge, no more | Missed (118 yards, no touchdown) |
Huntley Clears 125
YES on Tyler Huntley 125+ passing yards · 81.1¢ (-429) on Kalshi · 85.9% in the Sims · Result: hit, 201 yards
What I asked: "How often does Tyler Huntley throw for 125+ yards?"
The answer card from Ask the Sims, Sunday afternoon. Tap it to ask your own question about this game.
The quiet leg. A backup's passing lines get priced for a backup, and 125 yards is a low bar even for a run-first script: Huntley cleared it in 85.9% of the Sims. It paid the least of the four and cashed the most often, which is what you want from the leg that anchors a parlay.
| Contract | Price | Why | Result | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| BUY | YES on Tyler Huntley 125+ passing yards | 81.1¢ (-429) | 85.9% in the Sims; 5¢ of edge, the anchor leg | Hit (201 yards) |
| ALSO | YES on Tyler Huntley 150+ passing yards | 68.5¢ (-217) | 72.5% in the Sims; 4¢ of edge, better payout | Hit (201 yards) |
| SKIP | YES on Tyler Huntley 30+ rushing yards | 50.7¢ (-103) | 46.5% in the Sims; 4¢ against you | Missed (20 yards) |
What Moved Since October 11
The game the Sims built this page on was short and Baltimore's. The game that was played was long and Atlanta's until the last 40 seconds. Tyler Loop's 21-yard field goal opened it, then Andrews' first catch was stripped by Sydney Brown and Jessie Bates III ran the fumble back 36 yards: 7-3 Falcons with 8:03 left in the first. Penix's 5-yard touchdown throw to Kyle Pitts Sr. had it 14-9 at the half, Nick Folk's 23-yard kick made it 17-9, Hill ran 47 yards to the Atlanta 18 and Henry caught an 18-yard touchdown two plays later, with the two-point throw to Andrews falling incomplete, 17-15. Two more Folk kicks, from 34 and 48, had Atlanta up 23-15 with 2:31 left. Huntley then went 71 yards in six plays, hit Devontez Walker from 7 yards out with 40 seconds left, and Henry ran in the two-point try: 23-23. Two snaps later Penix was sacked by Tavius Robinson and fumbled, Atlanta recovered, and he left hurt with what ESPN's recap calls a rib injury. Tua Tagovailoa threw one pass, Penix came back for one incompletion, and Tagovailoa played the overtime. Baltimore took the overtime kickoff 68 yards in 14 plays, Huntley scored from a yard out with 2:57 left, and Kyle Hamilton intercepted Tagovailoa to end it. The Falcons-win contract closed the last full hour before kickoff at 63¢, was 66¢ at the 9 p.m. ET close, 69¢ at 10 with the half-time lead, 87¢ at 11 with Atlanta up five and the ball, and settled NO at 11:47 p.m. ET. The Ravens at 40.7¢, the side this page called fair and left alone, paid.
Penix cleared 200 because the game refused to be short. The 200+ contract closed the last full hour before kickoff at 63¢, was 35¢ at the 9 p.m. close with Atlanta ahead 7-3 on a defensive touchdown and Penix yet to complete a pass, and 29¢ at 10 p.m. with 83 yards on the board at halftime. Then he threw for 157 yards in the second half, all of it before an overtime he never played in: 16 plays and 74 yards on the drive that set up Folk's 34-yarder, 23 yards to Zachariah Branch with 6:15 left that took him from 174 to 197, and a 12-yard throw to Drake London at 4:58 that crossed 200. The 11 p.m. close was 99¢; the contract paid at 11:55 p.m. ET. He finished 19 of 32 for 240, with London catching seven for 118, and the 175+ row at 76.3¢ cashed along the way. Baltimore ran Henry 24 times, exactly the script, and Atlanta still got ten possessions, because a one-score game that goes to overtime is not a short game. The under lost at 40.7¢ on the one assumption every leg here leaned on.
Andrews never scored, and the fade cashed at 77.3¢ for the reason the card gave. He was targeted six times, caught four for 28 yards, had his first catch stripped for the Bates touchdown, was the target on the failed two-point pass in the third, and caught two balls in overtime, the second a 6-yarder to the Atlanta 4 two plays before the sneak. The goal-line snap went to Huntley, not to the tight end. His touchdown contract was 25¢ at the 9 p.m. close, 16¢ at 10, 6¢ at 11, and settled NO at 11:55 p.m. ET. Henry's touchdown, the row I passed on because it was priced 3¢ past the Sims, cashed at 10:23 p.m. ET on a catch, not a carry: 24 rushes for 102 yards and no rushing score, one reception for 18 and the touchdown.
Hill had the night the Sims described and no touchdown to show for it. Four carries for 73 yards, the 47-yarder among them, two catches for 5 yards on four targets, and not one touch inside the Atlanta 10. The inside-the-10 carries went to Henry, who ran to the 1 in the first quarter and lost two yards from there, then carried to the 1 in overtime, and the score from there went to Huntley. The contract closed the pre-kickoff hour at 12¢, was 11¢ at 9 p.m., 9¢ at 10, 3¢ at 11, and settled NO at 11:55 p.m. ET. Bijan Robinson (66.6¢, 17 carries for 86 yards and four catches for 32) and London (43.7¢, 118 yards) were the two Falcons I left alone, and neither scored either; Atlanta's touchdowns were Pitts and the defense.
Huntley cleared 125 late, 150 later, and 200 on the last throw before the winning sneak. The 125+ contract was 81¢ at the 8 p.m. ET close and again at 9, 95¢ at 10 with 97 yards at the half, and 84¢ at the 11 p.m. close with Huntley sitting on 121 yards, Baltimore down 20-15 and Atlanta driving for another field goal. The 11-yard throw to Rashod Bateman with 2:05 left took him from 121 to 132 and cleared the line; the 20-yarder to Bateman at 0:52 took him from 146 to 166 and cleared the 150+ Also row; the 6-yarder to Andrews in overtime took him from 195 to 201. He finished 24 of 32 for 201 and two touchdowns, ran six times for 20 yards, so passing on his 30+ rushing yards was right, and both passing contracts paid at 11:55 p.m. ET.
One contract on each of the four, at the 6:55 p.m. prices, cost $2.11 and paid back $2.00, 11¢ down as singles, and a parlay of the four died on two legs at once. The two that cashed did not need the script: a price set for a different quarterback, and a 125-yard bar a backup clears in a close game or a blowout. The two that lost needed the game to be short, and Baltimore's 24 Henry carries did not make it short, because the Ravens trailed from the first quarter until 40 seconds were left and Huntley threw 32 times, as many as Penix. The lesson I carry to Sunday night's Cowboys at Packers game in the Kalshi Combo Simulator: when the Sims hand you a game script, buy the legs that pay even if the script is wrong, and size the ones that depend on it like the longshots they are.
My Take
- Buy NO On Michael Penix Jr. 200+ Passing Yards At 40.7¢ (+146). The widest gap in the game: a Huntley script shortens Atlanta's night too. Result: lost, 240 yards in a game that went to overtime.
- Buy NO On Mark Andrews Scores A TD At 77.3¢ (-341), a fade of a price set for a different quarterback. Result: cashed, four catches and no touchdown.
- Buy YES On Tyler Huntley 125+ Passing Yards At 81.1¢ (-429), the anchor that cashes most often. Result: hit, 201 yards.
- Buy A Small YES On Justice Hill Scores A TD At 11.7¢ (+755), the passing-down back in a short-pass game. Result: lost, 73 yards on four carries and no touchdown.
Bijan Robinson (66.6¢ against 62.1%) and the Falcons to win (63.6¢ against 59.1%) were the two prices this page said the market got ahead of, and both settled at zero: Robinson never scored and the Falcons lost in overtime. Counting every row above, seven prices ran past the Sims. Those two, Andrews to score and Huntley 30+ rushing yards settled at zero; Penix 200+, Penix 175+ and Henry's touchdown paid.
Every price here includes Kalshi's taker fee. For how that fee compares with a sportsbook's cut, see Kalshi fees vs. sportsbook vig.
Prices: Kalshi, Sunday, Oct. 11, 2026, 6:55 p.m. ET, re-stamped in the text; the cards show the 11:29 a.m. CT prices. Kalshi quotes contracts in whole cents before the fee, so different props can share a price. Lamar Jackson (ankle) was out per ESPN; Zay Flowers and Marlon Humphrey were questionable and played. Results from the settled Kalshi contracts and ESPN's box score and play-by-play, re-pulled Sunday, Oct. 18, 2026, at 1:40 a.m. ET; the hourly prices in What Moved are the last trade of each Kalshi hourly candle, before the fee, and the hour named is the hour the candle closed. These are market prices and estimates, not predictions of fact and not financial advice.
More on this: Monday Night Football Picks: Stafford Won't Air It Out · Eagles vs Jaguars Kalshi Picks: Hurts Without His Weapons · Eagles vs Jaguars Anytime TD Picks: The 27-Cent Dive · Jalen Hurts Passing Yards in London: The Market Blinked · Thursday Night Football Picks: Surtain Out, Darnold Throws







