Updated August 16, 2026 · 12 min read · by Jake Hari
The Quick Answer
NFL Comeback Player of the Year odds on Kalshi open with Patrick Mahomes at 39 cents, back from the torn ACL and LCL that ended his 2025 season in Week 15. Behind him sit two quarterbacks who changed teams while hurt: Kyler Murray at 18 cents, now the Vikings' named starter after a Lisfranc injury, and Daniel Jones at 7 cents, the Colts' QB1 off a torn Achilles. Five AI models scored the entire board without being shown a single price. They agree with the market on the shape of the top, Mahomes included. Where they break from it is a number the board cannot show at all: roughly 23% of this award, by the panel's math, belongs to a player who has no contract on the board, the single biggest hole in the field. The full board, every model's number, and the reason a quarter of the probability is missing are below.
New to Kalshi event markets? Start here.
All prices in this piece were read from Kalshi on August 16, 2026, and are quoted as the last traded price in cents. This is a long-dated market on a regular season that has not kicked off; the contract runs to an expected expiration of March 23, 2027, and the award is announced at NFL Honors in February 2027. The numbers move as camps and the season unfold, and this page gets re-scored when the story does.
One structural note before the board, because it shapes every comparison underneath. The 16 listed contracts sum to 114 cents, not 100. Divide a price by 1.14 and you get its de-vigged figure, but read that number carefully: because the board has no "Other" contract, those de-vigged prices are conditional on the winner being one of the listed names. The panel's blend is not conditional; it prices the whole field, including the 23% it assigns to an unlisted winner. So the two are only apples-to-apples once you put them on the same footing. Rescale the panel to a listed-only basis (divide by 0.77) and, for example, its Mahomes number lands at 35%, right on top of the market's de-vigged 34%. The gap you will see between the panel's raw blend and the de-vigged price is, first and foremost, that 23% the panel moved off the board.
The Board
| Player | Team (comeback from) | Market | Panel blend |
|---|---|---|---|
| Patrick Mahomes | Kansas City Chiefs (torn ACL) | 39¢ | 27.2% |
| Kyler Murray | Minnesota Vikings (Lisfranc foot) | 18¢ | 11.6% |
| Malik Nabers | New York Giants (torn ACL) | 11¢ | 4.0% |
| Daniel Jones | Indianapolis Colts (torn Achilles) | 7¢ | 9.4% |
| Jonathon Brooks | Carolina Panthers (2nd torn ACL) | 5¢ | 1.6% |
| Micah Parsons | Green Bay Packers (torn ACL) | 4¢ | 3.0% |
| Travis Hunter | Jacksonville Jaguars (torn LCL) | 4¢ | 2.2% |
| Tank Dell | Houston Texans (multi-ligament knee) | 4¢ | 2.0% |
| Nick Bosa | San Francisco 49ers (torn ACL) | 4¢ | 1.8% |
| Fred Warner | San Francisco 49ers (ankle) | 4¢ | 0.8% |
| Tucker Kraft | Green Bay Packers (torn ACL) | 4¢ | 1.6% |
| George Kittle | San Francisco 49ers (torn Achilles) | 3¢ | 3.4% |
| Joe Burrow | Cincinnati Bengals (turf toe) | 3¢ | 6.4% |
| Michael Penix Jr. | Atlanta Falcons (torn ACL) | 2¢ | 1.2% |
| Kirk Cousins | Las Vegas Raiders (2023 Achilles) | 1¢ | 0.0% |
| Tie/Co-Winners | shared award | 1¢ | 0.8% |
| Any Unlisted Player (No Contract) | e.g. Jayden Daniels | — | 23.0% |
That last row is the story. The panel scored a 17th outcome the exchange does not sell, and blended it at 23%, its second-largest number. More on why below the seat table.
Hottest Prediction Markets Right Now
- 2028 Democratic presidential nominee · $181M traded
- FedEx St. Jude Championship Winner · $94M traded
- 2027 Pro Football Champion · $63M traded
- 2028 U.S. Presidential Election winner? · $60M traded
- 2028 Republican presidential nominee · $57M traded
- Pro Baseball Champion · $54M traded
Every market above links to our full AI model verdict; browse them all on the OddsShopper prediction markets hub, and see how every settled call actually scored on the full graded scoreboard.
Every Seat's Number
The top of the board, the names where the panel sits furthest from the market, and two where the panel and market nearly agree, with each model's estimate after the revision round.
| Outcome | Market (de-vigged) | Claude Opus | Claude Sonnet | GLM | Kimi | DeepSeek | Blend |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Patrick Mahomes | 34.2% | 28 | 27 | 26 | 25 | 30 | 27.2% |
| Any Unlisted Player | no contract | 25 | 25 | 20 | 25 | 20 | 23.0% |
| Daniel Jones | 6.1% | 10 | 9 | 9 | 9 | 10 | 9.4% |
| Joe Burrow | 2.6% | 6 | 6 | 7 | 7 | 6 | 6.4% |
| Malik Nabers | 9.6% | 4 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 4.0% |
| Kyler Murray | 15.8% | 13 | 12 | 11 | 10 | 12 | 11.6% |
| George Kittle | 2.6% | 3 | 4 | 4 | 3 | 3 | 3.4% |
| Kirk Cousins | 0.9% | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0.0% |
Every seat on this panel is graded against real market settlements — records to date: Claude Opus 85% on 578 graded calls · Claude Sonnet 84% on 556 graded calls · GLM 81% on 2,367 graded calls · Kimi 83% on 2,345 graded calls · DeepSeek 80% on 2,392 graded calls. Recomputed daily; the full scoreboard is public.
These are model estimates, not predictions of fact and not financial advice. Every number in this piece gets graded in public once the market settles, on the full graded scoreboard.
Five of the panel's eight seats scored this board. Each one saw the same fetched data card and no price at all, then read the other four anonymized boards and revised.
Free: The Weekly PM Market Brief — the panel's graded record, the week's biggest market-vs-model gaps, and what's spiking next. One email, Sundays.
More live boards from the same panel: NFL Coach of the Year, where John Harbaugh leads at 12¢ · NFL MVP 2026, where Josh Allen leads at 11¢ · NFL Defensive Player of the Year, where Myles Garrett leads at 19¢. Prices fetched August 16, 2026.
The Board's Missing Favorite
This is the fact that reorganizes the market. On the same August 16 morning these Kalshi prices were read, sportsbooks listed Jayden Daniels as one of the top two betting favorites for the award, in a range around +400 to +700. His 2025 season was wrecked by injury, a knee sprain, a hamstring, and a dislocated left elbow that limited him to about seven games, the kind of return the tightened criteria were written to honor. And he is not on the Kalshi board.
Neither is Aaron Donald, whose unretirement talk has him on the sportsbook version at +750 or so. The Kalshi event lists 15 players and a Tie bucket, and it has no "Other" or "Field" contract. If the award goes to anyone who is not one of those 15 names, every contract on the board resolves No. A trader who thinks Jayden Daniels wins this award cannot express that here. There is nothing to buy.
The panel treated that as what it is, a real slice of probability with no home on the board. All five seats carved out an unlisted bucket and gave it serious weight, from 20% to 25%, blending to 23%. That is not a rounding error. It is the second-most-likely outcome on the panel's board, and the market's structure hides it, because the listed prices are quietly conditional on the winner being one of the 15 names Kalshi chose to print. On an award whose sportsbook co-favorite is missing entirely, whether the exchange listed the eventual winner is a live question, and every price on the board is riding on the answer.
Patrick Mahomes, Kansas City: The Favorite, Fairly Priced
Mahomes is the correct favorite and the models say so. He tore his ACL and LCL in his left knee in Week 15 of 2025 against the Chargers, had December surgery, and per Kansas City has been fully cleared for training camp as a full participant with no limitations, targeting the September 14 opener against Denver. A marquee quarterback on a contender, returning from a season-ending knee injury, is what this award tends to reward: quarterbacks won it in seven straight seasons from 2018 through 2024 before Christian McCaffrey broke the streak in 2025.
His panel blend reads 27.2% against a de-vigged 34%, and it would be easy to call that a fade. It is not one. That 27% is an unconditional number, sharing the board with the 23% the panel parks on an unlisted winner. Put Mahomes on the same conditional-on-listed footing as the de-vigged price, dividing by 0.77, and he lands at roughly 35%, a hair above the market. Among the players Kalshi actually lists, the panel and the market see Mahomes almost identically. The only reason his unconditional number sits under the price is the quarter of the award the panel insists belongs off the board, and a dollar that would be Jayden Daniels's on a complete field is a dollar the market has nowhere to put but on the names it printed. Mahomes is not the edge here. The board's blind spot is.
Daniel Jones And Joe Burrow: Where The Panel Buys
The two clearest spots where the models sit above the market are both quarterbacks a tier or two down, and these are real edges, not artifacts of the off-board math: both clear the de-vigged price even before you rescale the panel up for the unlisted bucket, which only widens the gap.
Daniel Jones is a Colt now, not a Giant, and he is the panel's favorite value on the listed board: a 9.4% blend against a de-vigged 6.1%, with all five seats between 9 and 10. His comeback is a clean one, a torn Achilles roughly eight months ago, and Indianapolis has given him the job outright. Per the Colts he has not missed a first-team snap in camp and ran in a red-zone touchdown, with teammates saying he looks like he was never hurt. A healthy return plus an uncontested starting role is precisely the resume voters reward, and the market has him seventh.
Joe Burrow is the other one, 6.4% against a de-vigged 2.6%. He is fully cleared from the turf-toe surgery that cost him roughly nine games, he will wear a protective plate, and Cincinnati's offense gives him the production ceiling the award demands. The panel's one hesitation is history: Burrow has already won this award twice, in 2021 and 2024, and a third would be rare. That voter-fatigue drag is why the seats capped him in the single digits rather than pushing him toward Murray. But even capped, three cents is too cheap for a healthy Burrow.
Kyler Murray And Malik Nabers: Two The Panel Splits On
The market's second and third choices get opposite treatment from the panel.
Kyler Murray, at 18 cents, is a near-perfect match once you adjust for the off-board mass: an 11.6% blend that rescales to about 15% on a listed-only basis, against a de-vigged 15.8%. His case got stronger during the revision round, not weaker. He was released by Arizona, signed in Minnesota, and on August 11 was named the Vikings' Week 1 starter over J.J. McCarthy, which resolved the biggest question hanging over him. His comeback, a 2025 mid-foot Lisfranc injury that cost him about a dozen games, fits the criteria. The new offense and the lingering foot-health questions some analysts still flag are why the panel does not push past the market rather than sitting on it. Real candidate, fairly priced.
Malik Nabers is the panel's hardest fade on the board: 4.0% against a de-vigged 9.6%, with every seat at exactly 4. The talent is not the question; the timeline is. As of August 13 he was still in a red no-contact jersey, catching a handful of passes but not yet a full participant in a camp practice, his torn ACL from Week 4 of 2025 still governing his workload. A receiver who might not be full-go for the opener against Dallas is a hard sell for a full-season award, and wide receivers already win this less often than quarterbacks. The market is paying 11 cents for a story the panel thinks needs to clear a medical hurdle first.
Where The Panel Changed Its Mind
Every seat revised its board after reading the others anonymously. Three moves were large enough to matter, and one telling non-move.
The unlisted bucket grew as the seats read each other. Kimi lifted it from 18% to 25%, and its revised reasoning is blunt about why:
OTHER (25%)—Jayden Daniels (#2 book favorite, multi-injury) plus Donald. — Kimi
DeepSeek made the same move, from 15% to 20%. The seats that started lowest on the off-board mass moved toward the seats that started highest, which is the convergence you want to see: reading the others' reasoning pulled the panel together on the point rather than apart.
Opus made the board's biggest single-name revision, doubling Kyler Murray from 6% to 13% after the starter news registered across the panel:
Murray (13) — named Vikings Week-1 starter overcoming Lisfranc; foot uncertainty caps him. — Claude Opus
Sonnet did the quieter version of the same thing on Daniel Jones, lifting him from 4% to 9%:
Jones 9 (clean Achilles return, unquestioned Colts QB1, camp looking sharp). — Claude Sonnet
And one seat held its ground where it counted. DeepSeek kept Mahomes at 30 through both rounds, the panel's high number on the favorite, and still landed below the market's 39 cents:
Mahomes (30%) - ACL return, elite production, Chiefs' contender status. — DeepSeek
The panel's most bullish seat on Mahomes was still fading him. That is the tell on the favorite.
What Would Change The Panel's Mind
Four things, all checkable, with the direction each pushes the board.
- Kalshi lists Jayden Daniels (or he gets healthy and hot). The single biggest swing on this board. If the exchange adds a Daniels contract, the 23% unlisted bucket collapses into a real price and every listed number re-bases downward, Mahomes most of all. If Daniels instead suffers a setback, that mass flows back onto the favorites.
- Mahomes opens Week 1 without restriction. He targets the September 14 game against Denver. A clean, unrestricted start makes the panel's 27% look conservative; a PUP move or a snap count sends it toward the market's read of a healthier field behind him.
- Malik Nabers sheds the no-contact jersey. His 4% assumes a slow ramp. If he is cleared for full practice and plays the opener against Dallas, the gap to the market's 9.6% closes fast; if the ACL keeps him limited into September, the panel's fade is vindicated.
- A catastrophic-injury returnee gets a clean Week 1 clearance. Tank Dell (dislocated knee, torn ACL, MCL and LCL) is the most severe comeback story on the board, and severity is what this award now prizes. Houston has called his Week 1 status uncertain. If he is cleared and producing, the ultimate-narrative dark horse moves.
Dark Horses The Panel Won't Dismiss
George Kittle, San Francisco (3¢, 3.4% blend). The panel's cleanest small-number lean. Kittle tore his Achilles in the January playoff win over Philadelphia, opened camp on PUP, and mid-camp reporting has "high confidence" he plays Week 1 against the Rams. A dramatic playoff-injury origin and a return to a featured role is a made-for-voters story. The drag is position: a tight end has won this award once in the modern span, Rob Gronkowski in 2014.
Tank Dell, Houston (4¢, 2.0% blend). Kimi and Opus both flagged him as the board's severity play. A dislocated knee with three torn ligaments is as bad as it gets, and he is off the PUP list and back in team drills. The whole case rests on Week 1 availability, which Houston has pointedly declined to promise.
Tucker Kraft, Green Bay (4¢, 1.6% blend). DeepSeek's dark horse. Kraft returned to full team practice in mid-August, roughly nine months after a torn ACL, and caught a touchdown from Jordan Love in his first session back. The Packers plan to manage his snaps through roughly midseason, which caps the counting stats an award voter looks for.
Micah Parsons, Green Bay (4¢, 3.0% blend). A real ACL return and a top-tier talent, but the panel priced in the calendar: he opened camp on the PUP list and his own most-optimistic return is Week 6. A candidate who misses the first month-plus is fighting the schedule as much as the field.
The Market Card
The event is KXNFLCPOTY-27 on Kalshi. Each contract reads the same way, with only the name changing: "If Patrick Mahomes wins the Pro Football AP Comeback Player of the Year in the 2026-27 season, then the market resolves to Yes." The board carries an expected expiration of March 23, 2027.
The award is the Associated Press Comeback Player of the Year, chosen by a nationwide panel of 50 AP media members on a top-five ballot and announced at the NFL Honors ceremony during Super Bowl week, so the 2026-season winner is named in February 2027. One detail matters more than the mechanics: in June 2024 the AP clarified the criteria, stating that the award is meant "to honor a player who has demonstrated resilience in the face of adversity by overcoming illness, physical injury or other circumstances that led him to miss playing time the previous season." That clarification, which followed Geno Smith's 2022 win as a converted backup and Joe Flacco's 2023 win off a career lull, steers voters toward documented injury returns and away from pure job-battle bounce-backs. It is why the panel put Kirk Cousins, a healthy 2025 backup whose last injury, a torn Achilles, dates to the 2023 season, at zero, even though he opens 2026 as the Raiders' listed starter.
The structural quirk covered above bears repeating in the card: this board has no "Other" contract. It lists 15 players and a Tie, and if the winner is anyone else, all 16 contracts resolve No. The Tie/Co-Winners contract resolves Yes only if the award is formally shared.
Sportsbooks price the same award in American odds rather than cents, with a promo-driven read on the futures side. Our sportsbook-side breakdown of this race, and the quarterback pattern behind it, is in NFL Comeback Player of the Year odds 2026.
Kalshi contracts are CFTC-regulated event contracts, not sportsbook wagers, and trading is 18+. Availability varies by platform and location.
Settlement Timeline
| What | When |
|---|---|
| Preseason | August 2026 |
| Regular Season | September 2026 to January 2027 |
| Award Announced | NFL Honors, Super Bowl week, February 2027 |
| Contract Expected Expiration | March 23, 2027 |
This page is re-scored when the story moves. Prices as of August 16, 2026.
The Bottom Line
The market and the panel agree on the shape of the top: Patrick Mahomes is the Comeback Player of the Year favorite, and among the listed names the panel prices him right where the market does. The disagreements underneath are smaller and specific. The panel buys Daniel Jones and Joe Burrow a tier down, prices Kyler Murray in line, and fades Malik Nabers until his knee clears.
But the real finding is not on the listed board at all. Nearly a quarter of this award, by the panel's math, belongs to a player Kalshi did not print a contract for, with one of the sportsbooks' top-two favorites sitting in that gap. A field this narrow only settles Yes if the exchange listed the winner. On this award, in this season, holding any of these contracts carries that assumption whether the holder means it to or not. The season starts in September, and the answer arrives in February.
