Bucky Irving scored twice in Tampa Bay's 24-16 win at Dallas on Thursday night, so the lead pick on this page cashed at +190. The best touchdown bet left in Week 5 is Michael Wilson: YES on the Cardinals receiver to score Sunday against Detroit, 39.6¢ (+153) on Kalshi as of Sunday midday.
I asked the Sims about every pick again Friday morning. One didn't survive: the Jonathan Taylor fade, because his price finally matches the Sims. I also pulled Raheim Sanders: he's a backup running back, and the Sims run high on those. Josh Downs and Nico Collins take their places.
Ask The Sims your own TD question.Every pick below is a real answer from the free Kalshi Combo Simulator: type a player, and it counts how often he scores across 10,000 simulated games and checks Kalshi's price. Try Does Michael Wilson score a TD? or Does Nico Collins score a TD?, or ask about anyone in any Week 5 game.
Wilson Scores Against Detroit
YES on Michael Wilson scores a TD · 39.6¢ (+153) on Kalshi · Lions at Cardinals, Sunday 4:25 p.m. ET, Fox
Tap the card to open Wilson's question in Ask The Sims.
Detroit has allowed 30 or more points in three of its four games. Safety Brian Branch was ruled out Friday and corner Rock Ya-Sin Friday night, on top of safety Kerby Joseph, who has been out since August.
The Sims make this the highest-scoring game left on the Week 5 board, with Detroit the clear favorite. Arizona will have to throw to keep up, and lately Jacoby Brissett throws to Wilson: 30 targets over the last two games, more than Trey McBride.
Wilson has one touchdown to show for all of that work. I don't see that lasting against this secondary, and neither do the Sims. Saturday added a reason: the Cardinals are finalizing a trade of Marvin Harrison Jr. and told him he will be inactive against the Lions, per ESPN's Adam Schefter, which leaves Wilson and McBride as the only Arizona pass-catchers with a real target history. Wilson's YES went from 36.6¢ Friday morning to 38.6¢ by Saturday afternoon and 39.6¢ by Sunday midday, and DraftKings and FanDuel shortened him further Saturday, to +150 and +140, so Kalshi's +153 was still the longest of the three against Saturday's sportsbook prices. Saturday's Sims, run after the news, have him scoring in 46.3% of games. That's the bet.
Jameson Williams is the second buy in the same game, on Detroit's side and now 4¢ cheaper than Wilson. He had 102 yards last week, and the Sims have him scoring in about four of every ten games.
| Contract | Price | Why | |
|---|---|---|---|
| BUY | YES on Michael Wilson scores a TD | 39.6¢ (+153) | 46.3% in the Sims; Arizona's most-targeted player the last two weeks, and Harrison is inactive |
| BUY | YES on Jameson Williams scores a TD | 35.6¢ (+181) | 39.7% in the Sims; +165 at DraftKings, +175 at FanDuel |
| SKIP | YES on Trey McBride scores a TD | 47.7¢ (+110) | 44.1% in the Sims; costs 8¢ more than Wilson |
Jeremiyah Love carries no injury designation for Sunday, and the Sims had him playing, so Wilson's 46.3% already assumes Arizona's rookie running back is on the field.
See it in the Sims: Does Michael Wilson score a TD? →
Downs Is The Colts Buy
YES on Josh Downs scores a TD · 28.4¢ (+252) on Kalshi · Colts at Steelers, Sunday 1 p.m. ET, CBS
Alec Pierce is on injured reserve, and Keenan Allen, questionable all week, is active Sunday, so Josh Downs is no longer the only healthy wideout in Daniel Jones' rotation; Kalshi still prices him 12¢ above Allen. He drew 20 targets across Weeks 2 and 3, dipped to four last week, and still hasn't scored this season. Both sportsbooks had him at +230 Saturday, still shorter than he trades on Kalshi. Saturday his market was the widest on this page, 26¢ bid and 28¢ ask, and a resting bid at 27¢ beat lifting the offer. Sunday midday it's 26¢ bid and 27¢ ask, so a 27¢ bid just crosses the offer: lift it at 28.4¢ all-in, or rest at 26¢ and wait.
| Contract | Price | Why | |
|---|---|---|---|
| BUY | YES on Josh Downs scores a TD | 28.4¢ (+252) | 32.4% in the Sims; +230 at both sportsbooks |
| SKIP | YES on Tyler Warren scores a TD | 29.4¢ (+240) | 25.6% in the Sims; the Colts' tight end now costs 1¢ more than Downs with a lower hit rate |
| SKIP | YES on DK Metcalf scores a TD | 36.6¢ (+173) | 33.6% in the Sims; one touchdown in four games |
See it in the Sims: Does Josh Downs score a TD? →
Collins Is Houston's Passing Game
YES on Nico Collins scores a TD · 38.6¢ (+159) on Kalshi · Texans at Titans, Sunday 1 p.m. ET, CBS
Tank Dell and Jayden Higgins are on injured reserve, so Houston's passing game runs through Nico Collins. He has played two games this season and scored three touchdowns in them.
| Contract | Price | Why | |
|---|---|---|---|
| BUY | YES on Nico Collins scores a TD | 38.6¢ (+159) | 45.6% in the Sims; +120 at DraftKings and +135 at FanDuel Saturday, so Kalshi was the best price |
| SKIP | YES on David Montgomery scores a TD | 42.7¢ (+134) | 40.7% in the Sims, and Woody Marks has Houston's last two rushing scores |
See it in the Sims: Does Nico Collins score a TD? →
Fade Henderson If Stevenson Plays
NO on TreVeyon Henderson scores a TD · 66.6¢ (-199) on Kalshi Sunday, up from 52.7¢ Friday · Raiders at Patriots, Sunday 1 p.m. ET, CBS
TreVeyon Henderson and Rhamondre Stevenson split New England's carries almost evenly at Buffalo, and Stevenson got the touchdown. Friday morning both backs traded near a coin flip, the Sims had each of them scoring about 40% of the time, and Henderson was the pricier of the two, so the buy was his NO at 52.7¢:
That price is gone. Henderson's YES dropped from 51.8¢ Friday morning to 37.6¢ around midday ET Friday on heavy volume, sat at 35.6¢ Saturday and ticked back to 37.6¢ Sunday midday, so his NO now costs 66.6¢ (-199), still more than the 56.5% Saturday's Sims give it. Same rule as the Taylor fade below: I was fading the price, and the price moved first. Saturday's Sims have his YES at 43.5%, above the YES price too, but the Sims are shakier on running backs than on receivers, the sportsbooks (+165 and +155 Saturday) sit closer to Kalshi than to the Sims, and I'm not chasing a 15-cent move on a backfield number. Stevenson's YES slipped in the same Friday window, from 47.7¢ to 43.7¢, so the move wasn't Stevenson news; he is active, per Sunday's inactives report. The NO comes back only under 56¢, and the 56.5% assumes he plays, which he will. At Sunday's price, put the stake on Collins.
| Contract | Price | Why | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wait | NO on TreVeyon Henderson scores a TD | 66.6¢ (-199) | 56.5% in the Sims with Stevenson playing; a buy only back under 56¢ |
| SKIP | YES on TreVeyon Henderson scores a TD | 37.6¢ (+166) | 43.5% in the Sims; down from 51.8¢ Friday |
| SKIP | YES on Rhamondre Stevenson scores a TD | 42.7¢ (+134) | 39.3% in the Sims; he's active Sunday |
See it in the Sims: Does TreVeyon Henderson score a TD? →
Why Taylor And Sanders Came Off
Thursday morning's Colts pick was NO on Jonathan Taylor to score. Taylor has six rushing touchdowns in four games; I was fading the price, never the player, and that price is gone:
The Sims run low on lead backs, and Taylor's YES is cheaper on Kalshi than at either sportsbook. If you want a Colts running back bet, that's the one. I'd still rather have Downs at the longer price.
Raheim Sanders was this page's long shot at +755. The Sims hand out rushing touchdowns by share of carries, which runs high on backups and low on lead backs. Thursday's prices showed it: the Sims had Dallas backup Tyler Goodson at 22% when the sportsbooks implied about 13%.
Sanders is Cleveland's backup, with six carries all season, and the sportsbooks price him right where he trades on Kalshi. Only the Sims think he's cheap, so I'm siding with the books. On receivers the Sims sat close to the sportsbooks Thursday, which is why both replacements are receivers.
| Contract | Price | Why | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Off | NO on Jonathan Taylor scores a TD | 44.7¢ (+124) | Thursday's pick; it wins 41.1% of the Sims now |
| Fair | YES on Jonathan Taylor scores a TD | 59.7¢ (-148) | 58.9% in the Sims; -175 and -185 at the sportsbooks |
| Off | YES on Raheim Sanders scores a TD | 11.7¢ (+755) | Browns at Jets; +750 and +700 at the sportsbooks |
See it in the Sims: Does Jonathan Taylor score a TD? →
Irving Scored Twice
YES on Bucky Irving scores a TD · bought at 34.5¢ (+190) · won Thursday
Irving caught a 5-yard touchdown from Jalon Daniels, ran in another from the 1, and finished with 165 rushing yards in Tampa Bay's first win of the season. Javonte Williams, the Skip on Thursday's table, scored from the 1. CeeDee Lamb, the Fair, didn't score.
| Thursday's call | Contract | Price | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| BUY | YES on Bucky Irving scores a TD | 34.5¢ (+190) | Won; he scored twice |
| Fair | YES on CeeDee Lamb scores a TD | 49.7¢ (+101) | Lamb didn't score |
| SKIP | YES on Javonte Williams scores a TD | 67.6¢ (-209) | Williams scored from the 1 |

The Irving card as it stood Thursday morning, before the game.
My Take
- Buy YES on Michael Wilson scores a TD at 39.6¢ (+153). Thirty targets in two weeks, Marvin Harrison Jr. inactive, and Detroit missing two safeties and a corner. Jameson Williams at 35.6¢ (+181) is the second buy in the same game.
- Buy YES on Josh Downs scores a TD at 28.4¢ (+252). Twenty targets across Weeks 2 and 3, at a longer price than either sportsbook had him Saturday.
- Buy YES on Nico Collins scores a TD at 38.6¢ (+159). Three touchdowns in his two games, and Houston's passing game runs through him.
- Wait on NO on TreVeyon Henderson scores a TD. It costs 66.6¢ (-199) after Friday's move, above the Sims' 56.5%; it's a small buy only back under 56¢, and Rhamondre Stevenson is active.
NO on Jonathan Taylor and YES on Raheim Sanders are off the board.
Every Week 5 game still to be played, through Bills at Rams on Monday night, is in the free Kalshi Combo Simulator. Pick a game and Ask The Sims about any player in plain words.
Kalshi prices on this page (taker fee included) were re-checked Sunday, Oct. 11, at about 11:45 a.m. CT, before the 1 p.m. ET kickoffs. Colts-Steelers, Texans-Titans and Raiders-Patriots: Sims percentages and the Downs and Collins cards from Saturday's Sims, Oct. 10, with DraftKings and FanDuel prices as of about 12:35 p.m. CT Saturday. Lions-Cardinals: Saturday's Sims, run at 1:24 p.m. CT, with the Wilson card and DraftKings and FanDuel prices as of about 1:33 p.m. CT Saturday. The Henderson, Taylor and Irving cards and the Taylor and Sanders tables are as they stood when those calls were made.
More on this: Eagles vs Jaguars Anytime TD Picks: The 27-Cent Dive · CeeDee Lamb Receiving Yards Tonight: Don't Buy a Line · Patriots vs Bears Anytime TD Picks: Maye At 20 Cents · Texans vs Jaguars Anytime TD Picks: Fade Woody Marks · Seahawks vs Broncos Anytime TD Picks: Seven In Five Games








